JESUS Next year the “Jesus Seminar” takes to the road and visits the UK. DUNCAN PARK, organiser of the tour, explains what it’s all about, and urges Sea of Faith to make the aquaintance of the man who didn’t found Christianity but did start a revolution
Jesus: a peasant with attitude Jesus can still put some Sea Faith members’ teeth on edge. Many fled to this Network bruised and battered by the “Name above all Names”.
Not surprisingly, therefore, when I suggested Sea of Faith might be interested in doing business with the Jesus Seminar there was a certain bristling of hairs and raising of eyebrows. It might reassure those who have marched out of the front door of the Church in disgust to know that, according to Robert Funk, founder of the Jesus Seminar, Jesus has walked out with them.
This is not the Jesus that, for many, slid long ago into mythological twilight: that Jesus has nothing to say that speaks to our condition. But by putting Jesus into an historical context, the supernaturalist icon of postNicene theology is released from the doctrinal layers that have entombed him. Once the cultural rubble is removed, we find a remarkable visionary, a secular prophet, a sage or, as Jesus Seminar co-founder John Dominic Crossan puts it, “a peasant with attitude’: a Jesus that SoFers can do business with.
This religious subversive is in stark contrast to the bloodied and mutilated Jesus of the Church, whose broken body is an icon for its own self-loathing and its world-denying, power hungry, supernatural rage at being merely human. The clergy must cry mea culpa for keeping this bizarre, pathetic Jesus pinned to the cross. No historical criticism, form criticism or, indeed, any kind of criticism has reached the pews from the seminaries. Generations of clergy have known perfectly well the essence of post-Enlightenment biblical criticism and have kept it chained to the pulpit of parish piety. To the last gasp, the Church has betrayed her children.
The evolution of the Jesus Seminar was almost inevitable, given the obsession of a handful of gospel specialists (Funk, Crossan, Borg et al) to renew the quest for the historical Jesus. Funk, a leading biblical scholar (Guggenheim Fellow, Fulbright Senior Scholar and distinguished author) declared at the inception of the Jesus Seminar in 1985, that “We are about to embark on a momentous enterprise. We are going to inquire simply, rigorously after the voice of Jesus, after what he really said.
In this process we will be asking a question that borders the sacred, that even abuts blasphemy, for many in our society. As a consequence, the course we shall follow may prove hazardous. We may well provoke hostility. But we will set out, in spite of the dangers, because we are professionals and because the issue of Jesus is there to be faced, much as Mt.
Everest confronts the team of climbers.” The thirty-five scholars who turned up at Berkeley to hear Funk declare war on religious illiteracy are now over two hundred Fellows of the Jesus Seminar. Something of the refreshing vigour of the early Church seems to have rubbed off on them. Rather than indulge in the wilful sadness (which Dante rightly put in the third circle of hell) and angry nihilism that characterises much contemporary radicalism, Funk & Co have set about starting all over again, right from Jesus. Not a bad place to start.
The methodology of this is as transparent as it is controversial. It was at considerable cost that the academic study of religion won its independence from ecclesiastical control in the seventeenth century. Individual scholars were often treated as heretics and forced to clothe their findings in unintelligible jargon. Enter the Jesus Seminar, making the scholarship of religion comprehensible to “the whosoever” and rejecting outright the ivory tower philosophy. Not only are its voting methods open, public and widely published, but Fellows take the Seminar “on-the-road” (a radical version of the evangelical tent meeting?) throughout the USA and beyond.
Like the Sea of Faith, the Jesus Seminar has serious enemies in the comic strip world of tabloid theology.
Funk has never avoided the front-line, perhaps knowing he is armed with awesome weapons. Unlike many scholars, he is not attacking the Bible but attacking with the Bible, as it is the New Testament documents themselves that make him radical. He is not chucking philosophers at faith; he is chucking Jesus at fantasy. Thus he takes his argument right into the fundamentalist camp, where he is under intense and continuous attack from just about everyone, including, of course, the so-called “Moral Majority”. This is not just scholarship — this is heroic scholarship.
One of the dynamic contributions of Jesus Seminar thinking is to allowa nonrealist spiritual life to co-exist with a noncredal Jesus — an historical Jesus set free from history. We enter what I choose to call a post-realist experience:
Christ in us (where else?); the mystical joy of hope (why not?). We share in a community of faith that celebrates the great spiritual myths of our culture. Like Jesus Seminar Fellow and author Marcus Borg, we can discover “the God we never knew” or “meet Jesus again for the first time”. Like Borg, we can know the transforming power of the Gospel because of our pilgrimage away from realism. Of course this is as much an emotional as an intellectual challenge.
I accept that not all SoFers will want or need to make this pilgrimage and the quest-for-the-historical-anything (particularly Jesus) can be wearisome for many postmodern radicals. Others are on a philosophical trajectory entirely beyond the orbit of religious signs. But for we SoFers still deeply involved in the life of the Church, much that the Jesus Seminar offers gives back the right to be thus involved. Its Jesus subverts the religious tradition that has entombed him. By encountering the pre-Nicene Jesus, we experience a kind of resurrection in reverse, like a film run backwards. He is risen on the far side of the myth and comes alive in the immediacy of his uncompromising humanity.
Coming soon to a venue near you...
Robert Funk is crossing the Atlantic next spring on a six week Jesus Seminar OnThe-Road organised by the newly created Pilgrim Network. It is a busy and full itinerary and will include three Sea of Faith conferences (Manchester, Taking Leave of Jesus?, organised by the SoF steering committee and the North West SoF Group; Scotland, (title to be decided), and Colchester Let My People Know!), with other distinguished scholars, theologians and churchmen participating in some of these events, including Bishop Richard Holloway.
Seminars are planned at the universities of Cambridge, Oxford, Sheffield, Derby, London and Birmingham with others sponsored by various church and independent bodies. There will also be four “pilgrim retreats” on offer, where it will be possible to have a close encounter with the man himself.
I am bringing the Jesus Seminar OnThe-Road to the UK because I believe that Biblical scholarship of this ilk will do more than all the philosophy on earth to provide effective weaponry against fundamentalism. My feeling is not only that Sea of Faith should do business with the Jesus Seminar, but that it must.
Duncan Park is a member of the Sea of Faith steering committee and organiser of the Pilgrim Network. Enquiries about the Jesus Seminar On-The-Road to the UK next Spring should be sent to him at: