Don Cupitt, After All FAITH DESPITE ADVERSITY Margie Tolstoy Faith in Doubt: Non-Realism and Christian Belief, by David Hart (Mowbray), £8.99 paperback In the introduction we learn that David Hart grew up in a traditional Anglican parish where the Book of Common Prayer of 1662 had as much authority as the Bible. He writes: "In such a setting I fell in love with the majestic world of church language and rituals... but I knew all the time that there were parts of myself that had no place in that very closed world". Despite these reservations, he was ordained into the ministry and is now Senior Anglican Chaplain to Loughborough University and Colleges. Another autobiographical detail tells about his sympathy for rebellious and extreme people, partly, he writes, because "inside myself I came to discover a rebel and an extremist". It is one of the few candid moments in the book. Having thus been presented with a context, one is engaged with an increased sense of curiosity and compassion.
The rebelliousness strikes sooner than expected. This non-realist perspective on faith was delivered into the hands of the publishers on the Feast of the Transfiguration 1992. Just the sort of thing a non-realist would draw your attention to! For the likes of you and me, it is August 6, and if you are still intrigued, read Mark chapter 9.
In the first sentence of the first chapter the author confidently exclaims that "faith in our century in the West has come of age". It is a statement nearly as grandiose as that of Fukuyama announcing the end of history. Modest it is not. This faith, he asserts, "can, independently of its traditions, stand up and show itself to be that developed, sophisticated but flawed, human creation that it is". It is set over against the outdated (and immature) notion of a personal relationship with a loving God, because this assumes an external deity which is no longer acceptable to people in this day and age. David Hart writes: "A maturer understanding denies the believer such easy immunity from suffering".
I cannot go along with, nor indeed respect, this casual treatment of a more traditional understanding of religious faith, even though it may sound like music to the ears of some SoF devotees. The choice here is that faith is either a human creation or a belief in the existence of a supernatural sugar-daddy in the sky. That is an extremist and misleading parody of a very diverse, complex and mysterious phenomenon we call religion. It is yet another example of the kind of dogged inflexibility that is also reflected in the political life of this country. Either you command or you permit.
Had I not agreed to review this book I would probably have abandoned it then and there. That would have been a pity, because to my surprise I discovered that it really takes off at the bottom of page 3, and from there onwards is a delight. [There are 176 pages - Ed.] Due recognition is given to Don Cupitt, whose work has clearly influenced David Hart. Examples that unpack the notion of a non-realist faith are provided by a diverse company of people, from Shakespeare to Woody Allen, Wittgenstein, Kierkegaard and Kant. Nietzsche's Zarathustra adds an important ingredient to the non-realist position: the will to power. This gives us another glimpse into the private world of the author: "I was twenty-two and was walking on a beautiful summer's day to a temporary job - I recited to myself the joyful words of the audacious prophet Zarathustra, 'He who with eagle jaws grasps the abyss, he has courage'. I realized at that moment the joyful truth that, as my life lay before me, there was no other person than myself who would take responsibility for the shaping thereof. There were parents, there were teachers, there were friends and colleagues, but the connections I had were subject to my will, and I was not subject to the will of any other authority".
That is the key to understanding David Hart's version of non-realist faith. It reaffirms self-esteem, it gives breathing space, it liberates. And in the second chapter we are given examples of the freedom that a critical and imaginative faith perspective brings to the understanding of the crucial concepts of resurrection and the dead within Christianity. There are illustrations from the world of modern theology, painting, literature and music. This chapter truly sings and ends with an example of non-realist resurrection!
The next chapter concerns the body and sexuality. We read that "without a real God, there is no universal hierarchy and equally no fixed personal sexual identity". It is regrettable that the God over against which non-realism is placed always plays the role of villain. I consider that to be a serious weakness in the non-realist camp. But the intelligent refutation of a dual anthropology is refreshing and timely, and the discussion of the changing patterns in human relationships is entertainingly and sensitively presented. But in all honesty, I do not share the view that as individuals we are freely able to create the persons we want to be, in our bodies and in our world of bodies. That is true only up to a point and some are a lot better at it than others, even, I am sure, among liberated non-realists. The implicit condemnation of all the people who fail to do so and suffer mental or physical agonies in this delicate area of human relationships cannot really be justified.
Every religious perspective has its particular high risk areas, and the deification of the individual is always lurking in the wings here. The chapter on how and what non-realists worship is of particular interest. The notion of God is replaced by, for example, "our deepest concern", but David Hart admits that our collective worship will still be in the form of realist language - not least because many non-realists remain within the mainstream denominations. That this requires the "willing suspension of disbelief" is nicely accompanied by an illustration of Coleridge's epic poem The Ancient Mariner. Examples of theology and literature and personal observation are interestingly interwoven throughout. This is a thoughtful book and much of it is enjoyable. Whether it succeeds in making a case in favour of "losing the real for the good" is up to each reader.
Dietrich Bonhoeffer is brought onto the scene more than once and at the end of the book it is more or less suggested that his position is akin to that of a non-realist. My understanding is a little different. I think Bonhoeffer points the way forward for non-realism and Christian faith. Let me quote Bonhoeffer who, while he was in prison in 1944, wrote in the letter of July 16 to Eberhard Bethge the words on which the opening sentence of this book is a variation: "Anxious souls will ask what room there is left for God now; and as they know no answer to the question, they condemn the whole development that has brought them to such straits. And we cannot be honest unless we recognize that we have to live in the world etsi deus non daretur (as if God did not exist). And this is just what we do recognize - before God! God himself compels us to recognize it. So our coming of age leads us to a true recognition of our situation before God. God would have us know that we must live as men who manage our lives without him. The God who is with us is the God who forsakes us (Mark 15.34)... Before God and with God we live without God. God lets himself be pushed out of the world on to the cross. He is weak and powerless in the world, and that is precisely the way, the only way, in which he is with us and helps us".
No longer faith in doubt, but faith despite adversity.