Dear God

DEAR GOD Clare Short Dear God, As you know (or would know if you existed), I do not think that you exist. But I do have a strong concept of you and even a continuing relationship with you. In that sense, you do exist.

I freely admit that when I have been really bereft, I have appealed to you. I have always been honest about this. I say "God - if you are there - and you know that I think you are not - please help me." And then I smile to myself because I know that this means that I have to mobilise all my strength. And I always get through. So there is a sense in which the concept of the non-existent you is helpful to me.

I was brought up with a very strong idea of you. I come from long lines of Irish, Catholic families. One side of my family is from the beauty and unhappiness of South Armagh. The other from my great-great Grandad who escaped from the Irish famine to the safety of my own city of Birmingham.

It is interesting for me to reflect on what I would be if my father had stayed in Crossmaglen. Assuming that he had still managed to meet my mother and that I was still me, I am sure that I would still be a Catholic.

I have walked through the fields where my father's youngest brother keeps his cows, to visit 'our' Mass Rock. They are poor but beautiful fields (Catholic land is always the least fertile). At the top of the hill, there is a natural dip where the Mass Rock is hidden. Here, generations of my family and their neighbours risked their lives to practise their religion.

If I lived in a place where people persecuted me, discriminated against me and even possibly killed me for coming from the culture that I come from - then certainly I would still be with it. I would almost certainly have the same intellect and doubts that I have now. But I would go to Mass every Sunday - because they dared say that I should not. This is why I understand, in a deep way, the attachment of persecuted people to your religions.

As you know, I had a lovely childhood. I went to Catholic schools, learned my catechism, made my first communion and act of confession. I studied hard for confirmation and answered all the Bishop's questions. (He even accused my teachers of deliberately putting me at the front of the church). I did resent them saying my confirmation name had to be after Frances of Rome rather than Francis of Assisi.

But I dealt with it by deciding it was Francis, the animal lover, whatever they said. I walked in processions in my white dress and veil and carried flowers and sang "Mary, we crown thee with blossoms today At my girls' Catholic grammar school, I played netball and read lots of lovely books and learned a lot. I also took you very seriously. I got the Scripture prize after SOF Magazine 10, Summer 1992 9 my 0 levels. I also attended closely to the doctrine lessons. I really wanted to know what was good, right and true. I cared intensely about how we should live our lives and how we should organise the world. I still care about these things. That is why I am in politics.

So - funnily enough - you are largely responsible for where I have ended up.

I started to doubt your existence at the age of about 13. It was over whether people in India should have access to contraception. I decided that they should and that therefore the Pope was not infallible. It is strange looking back that the issue arose over India. I suppose it was because I would have hated it if any of my sisters and brothers had not been born. But perhaps I had a foreboding for my own life and that of my classmates.

The thing about Catholic teaching is that it is all so clear and it all hangs together. So, soon after I decided the Pope could not be infallible, I decided that you probably did not exist. When I voiced these doubts, one of my teachers said there were seven proofs of your existence. I waited excitedly to hear what they were. I was very disappointed. They did not prove it to me.

I have left you but I do still admire and like you. I am very grateful for my upbringing. It led me into my life search for what is good and right. I do hope that you do not think that this is arrogant - but it led me beyond you.

I do however understand the progressive nature of basic Christian teaching. My father told me, when I started to have my doubts, that Christianity was the religion of the slaves - that is how it spread through the Roman Empire. I also read about the English slave-owners in the Caribbean, persecuting those who baptised the slaves. They understood that, if everyone is equal in the sight of God, then slavery was an abomination - which it was. The slave-owners were hypocrites when they went to Church. There are still many like them in politics. I know you disapprove of them.

Although I come from this Christian background, I understand Christianity is not the only route to you. In my lovely Ladywood, we have every world religion.

Synagogues, Madrassas, Gurdwaras for each caste.

We have Buddhist temples and Asian Christian churches for those who wisely rejected a religion that put them in the bottom caste. We have a Hindu temple. There are Afro-Caribbean churches. My old church has a strong Vietnamese congregation. The English Churches struggle to make use of their massive and often beautiful buildings. Mrs Thatcher led them to "faith in the City". They are there, working with people of all faiths and none, for a more just community.

I learn a lot from all these gurus and holy books. I understand our search for you is a search for a moral order, a way of goodness and a place to ritualise the most important rites of passage. I have seen these people struggle to establish their churches, so they can take pride in who they are, celebrate the birth of children, their coming of age and their deaths. I remember vividly how important it was for us to have Catholic ritual to reach for to give honour to the death of my father. I am grateful to you for helping to evoke the rituals that make such momentous moments in life comforting and dignified.

Now I must end this letter to you. As you know, I think you do not exist. What I think you are is the quest for the goodness that is in us. What I think the devil is, is an encapsulation of the badness that is in us. What I think immortality is, is a dream for oppressed people that one day life will be fair. But it is also the fact that each of leaves scratches and reverberations behind us that go on forever and a way of saying that we remember and care for ever for those we have loved who are dead.

I cannot believe in you because I know you so well and I know that the way the world is does not square with your existence. But I am grateful for the concept of you because it helps to civilise us all.

CLARE SHORT is Labour M.P. for Birmingham Ladywood.

Reprinted, with permission, from the 1991 Christmas Supplement of New Statesman & Society.