Communication, Communion or Celebration?

Mark Rivett The SoF Network, as evidenced at its conferences and in the magazine, is struggling to develop a role which satisfies its membership. I experience this struggle when I attend either local group or more distant group meetings. During these meetings I often consider asking the basic questions that I ask families when I meet them "therapeutically". I would like to ask these questions here and see if the analogy from therapeutic practice clarifies the Network's position.

When I begin a conversation with a troubled family I ask "what do you want from this meeting?". Hopefully the individual answers will explain the needs of individual family members. Then I will want to know "what do you see as 'the problem'?" - a question which will help me explore the understandings that underlie the needs which we've described.

If we ask these of SoF members there will be many differences - but will there be commonalities into some groupings? Family therapists have stated that the replies to these enquiries generally fit three named categories. The first reply classifies the client as a "visitor" - that is, a general unease has motivated them to attend therapy but they are unable (as yet) to specify what is wrong or what their needs are. The second category of "complainants" are reacting against something which suppresses their needs and causes the "problem", but again, like visitors, they are unclear about the solution to the problem. The last group, "customers", are conscious of their needs, can define the problem (not overtly ascribing blame to others) and are working on what may be a solution.

Clearly the analogy between this typology and SoF should not be literal or extended too far: it is far too dogmatic and implicitly judgmental. But when I sit in SoF meetings I do hear three sorts of discourse: those who are reacting against the church (however it is conceived) as being dogmatic, traditionalist, etc; those who have a developed "immanentist" view of "God", where doctrine rather than structure is the problem; and those who are more non-realist in the post-modern sense.

I would suggest that the Network's difficulty in delineating its direction is because these different strands have not been acknowledged but subsumed under the label "we are a broad church". There is a fear that recognising difference will endanger our supposed unity. Or that describing too precisely will be to dogmatize and alienate some. However there is no reason why the broader movement cannot entail smaller, more cohesive groupings: difference-vitality needs to be maintained.

Let me go on - and perhaps my therapeutic analogy begins to creak a little here. It could be argued that the above divisions lead to separate views of the function of the Network as a whole. Thus someone who is seeing traditional church structure as "the problem" may be content to attend a non-denominational discussion group (the communication possibility of my title). Someone pursuing an immanentist theory of God may wish for the modern-day version of "fellowship" - a term I dislike for its sexist connotations, preferring the no less troublesome word communion. Lastly, the non-realists may be happy with these, may be able to retain their church traditions, but equally may wish to create a new vehicle to celebrate their faith. Of course, the latter option runs the risk of creating new dogma, exclusivity and "conversion", which will be resisted by many. But this is not an all or nothing business - it is a both/and and not an either/or situation.

Were some SoF members to pursue this possibility, what would a non-realist celebration look like? I guess it may involve Christian and Buddhist elements, it may have space for silence and spontaneity, it may recognise the values of ecology and, above all, it would be ironic about itself. I also suspect that the concept of priesthood/leadership would be radically altered.

It would be interesting to read of such celebrations in the magazine in the future.

Mark Rivett is a social worker and family therapist working in Cardiff SOFT FOCUS Richard Smith Having just become a member of the Network, I have had an opportunity to cast a fresh eye over copies of the magazine and other SoF literature. After a twenty-year religious quest without fitting easily into any orthodox religion or denomination I feel that here at last I may find kindred spirits.