City of Dreams

City of Dreams Michael Morton reflects on the Secular City and the City of God.

As a reflection on human, humanist and Christian thought, it is probably best to place them in the context of city life. Christianity began in houses and towns, and was scathing of the 'pagani'—country-folk who persisted in the old ways. Now we in Western Europe and especially in England have a unique experience of the decline of religion in the cities and post-urban sprawls Man, in the struggle for the emancipation of slavery and eventually of women, and in the need to preserve and nurture the earth.

Some evidence that the Church took up St Augustine and became part of this struggle, trying to change the human condition, can be illustrated by two examples.

During the 1940s, an Italian doctor called Carlo Levi was internally exiled to Italy's deep south by ‘Fourmillante cite, cite pleine de ré@ves’ _ the Fascist regime of Mussolini. He later wrote about his experiences and his stay C. Ba u d e laire inthe desperately poor hamlet of Aliano near Potenza. He called his book Christ as churches close to become museums or disappear completely. Although Christianity seems to be growing in other parts of the world, with ongoing global urbanisation the relation of the church, the city, and the Kingdom of God is a matter of universal significance.

The first cities emerged in such places as Catal Hitytik in modern Turkey, which were centres of agriculture and commerce. Humans, it seems, sit uneasily with the constant labour and migration that goes with hunting and farming. Cities were created from the yearning for a settled existence. But at the end of the Ancient World, when Rome fell in the West, St Augustine used the notion of the City of God to wrestle with the problem of why God had allowed Rome to be destroyed. It was not because Christians had deserted the old gods (for hadn't Troy and many pagan empires fallen too?). Nor was it just the will of God—inscrutable and unknowable—that had caused the downfall. In the perspective of eternity, no earthly city or kingdom was good in itself in the eyes of God. For Christians and virtuous pagans, what must endure is justice. States may come and pass away, but God’s just reign endures.

The growth of healthy urban life which made justice realisable dates from the Enlightenment, the foundation of the United States of America, and the French Revolution. The fearful scenes painted by Hogarth were gradually left behind. After enduring a time in the wilderness during the eighteenth century, Christian faith also revived after 1815, but many of its projects to affirm authentic humanity were being overtaken by secular action: in Utilitarian ethics, by Thomas Paine's Rights of Stopped at Eboli, for at Eboli near Naples the railway line gave out. Beyond, there was only wilderness and despair. So the people said: 'we are not Christians; Christ stopped at Eboli.' (Christians, in their dialect, meant simply ‘humans’, ‘people'.) The identification is significant. To be fully human and fully Christian have to be closely linked. It is the reality of Incarnation set in stern and practical terms.

Twenty years later, the Council bishops meeting at St Peters in Rome for Vatican II began to value the poor and afflicted as followers of Christ, as in Gaudium et Spes:

The joy and hope, the griefs and anxieties of the people of this age - especially those who are poor or in any way afflicted - these too are the joys and hopes, the griefs and anxieties of the followers of Christ.

Indeed, nothing human fails to find an echo in their hearts.

It is a brave but very risky assertion. It serves to show that we can realise and establish at last that this world is neither an exile, nor a ‘vale of tears’. Or if it is so, it can be transformed. The sayings of Jesus have an identical undertone. The possibility of the Kingdom and radical, humanitarian ethics have a lot in common.

Unhappily, this is something that is resisted by those who denigrate the world or who think that modern society is corrupt and obsessed with 'materialism', which no-one can ever define.

Yet modern society does have its dark side (and maybe one that is getting worse). There are rising incidents of racism in parts of England evidenced by the volume of support the British Nationalist Party received in the last local elections. There seems, also, to be an acceptance of inequality in wealth, opportunity, respect and social standing in the country. There is also a malevolence in criminality, and so the cheerful villain, the lovable rogue are characters from the distant past.

And no-one, it seems, can do anything about drug-abuse and even the government is worried; a sure sign that things are in danger of getting out of control.

In the face of this complexity, we have to say that while Christian faith may not make any specific difference, it may still make all the difference. In Easter there is a religious humanism which is a radical form of religious expression. Guided by religious symbols of transformation—life out of death, hope out of tragedy, and a bias towards the determined to shun publicity. So others faced by the power and the wealth of the Great Church, as it became the official religion and ideology of the late Roman Empire, adopted a similar pattern. People like Antony of Egypt and the desert hermits—and later Benedict, in the West—went into the wilderness, off the beaten track, to find peace and discover God.

In modern times a particularly good example is to be found in T. S. Eliot’s play, The Cocktail Party. The heroine, Celia, goes away to Africa where she meets an unpleasant, violent death at the hands of the very people she left to help. But the tone of the play wants to tell us that her death was really redemptive. In religious terms, of course, the same is supposed to be true of the lives and fates of Theresa of Lisieux and poor and alienated—the Christian humanist seeks to realise a hoped-for future. And when it arrives, it comes under scrutiny because the human project is never perfected. This future needs a divine touchstone. Hence, it is called the City of God. Christian faith makes a difference because it makes possible a wholehearted commitment to action that neither becomes fanatical, nor breaks down into gloomy inactivity; the modern malaise of feeling that we cannot do anything about anything important. The Kingdom of God collects these characteristics: it is the secular ideal of a complete, just and peaceful human society, but it is also open to a critique from without, that is, from God.

Christian humanism identifies the Kingdom or City of God with the needs of the poor and the alienated by addressing a strong critique against the control and power-structures inherent in modern society. It is not the only option for modern Christian faith, however.

Although the ideals and values of the Kingdom can readily be seen in our liberal, democratic world (which has been directly and indirectly influenced by Christian values in any case), there is another use of the symbols of transformation to ground the Passion and Resurrection in human life and experience.

In a spirituality that is more oblique, more passive, the Kingdom, so to speak, is played in an introverted minor key. We can introduce it by reflecting on just how much the edges and margins become important in the Gospel stories. Jesus is baptised at the waters’ edge, and he calls his first disciples from the edge of the lake. He calls people, too, from the edge of the road and the margins of the crowd. In the parable of the Good Samaritan, a man is attacked on the fringe of the desert—the Jerusalem-Jericho road—by brigands, who popularly live alienated, on the edge of civilisation.

Indeed, the whole Gospel narrative, apart from the Passion and its preface, takes place in Galilee, away from Jerusalem. In the parable, the Jerusalem establishment is represented by the Temple priests who pass by the action and miss the meaning.

This indirect kind of spirituality perhaps also has its origins in the style and behaviour of Jesus himself. He was constantly slipping away to be alone, he was adept at moving away, unnoticed from crowds, and seemed Maximilian Kolbe. In spite of their suffering, their admirable desire for God is redemptive for others.

In this spirituality we are able to explore another, darker, notion of the Kingdom. It moves away from the God of justice who expresses himself in the way things go in the world towards a God of love and peace, a deeper union with transcendence that has to do with the Buddha as much as with the Christ. As in the monastic movement, such a spirituality is where East and West meet.

The religious preoccupation with the City of God and a redemptive peace has been set aside by modern society. It has been replaced by nothing at all. There is a vague popular belief in progress, fuelled by government which promises to herald a better society. We have experienced the breakdown of a liberal optimism which stood society in such good stead since the nineteenth century. It failed mainly because its theories underestimated the human inclination to avoid the truth in the pursuit of selfinterest. Hardly a century after the American and French revolutions, writers were exploring the world not of enlightened self-interest in the best of all possible worlds, but the fog, filth and nightmare of the unreal city of modern life. The utopias of philosophers were balanced in people's imagination, and then in reality, by the descriptions of Dickens, Baudelaire and Dostoyevsky who made London, Paris and St Petersburg realms of poverty and neurotic motiveless crime. Soon public virtue and ideology became a ghost town into which anyone could ride and declare himself sheriff. Society and religion became pluralist, eclectic and fragmented with no fixed cycle of things or dominant myths to explain the world. All this knocks traditional, disciplined Christianity and casts doubt upon the cheerful optimism that is offered by modern life.

And yet we can see that the image of the city mixes reality with aspiration and hope. In scripture and history, an array or matrix of examples lead to a simple but happy conclusion—that the city is both a place and a hope, where you can be Christian and fully human, human and fully Christian at the same time.

Michael Morton is a member of the Sea of Faith Steering Committee, chair of its Publications Group, and is a Catholic Priest of St Winefried’s Parish, Sandbach.