Christianity Reformed or a Smorgasbord of Therapeutic Spiritualities?

Nigel Leaves asks is Christianity being reformed, according to Don’s original vision, or do we have a smorgasbord of therapeutic spiritualities?

There are two parts to this article. The first explores the impact of Cupitt’s TV series The Sea of Faith twenty years after it was broadcast in 1984. The second is to determine whether spirituality needs religion. These two themes may appear to be separate, but I want to propose that in fact they are intertwined. Indeed, Cupitt’s ‘original vision’ twenty years ago is being met head-on by a populist spirituality revolution of the new millennium that both disturbs and challenges that vision. It also forces us in Sea of Faith to ‘contemplate the next twenty years’ and to analyse where we are going and what is our purpose. This article pits Cupitt’s original vision against the many populist forms of spirituality that have emerged in postmodernity.

Part |: Cupitt’s ‘original vision’ of a reformed Christianity If there is one incident in the six one-hour episodes that I think sums up what Cupitt was attempting to do, it would be the closing scene of Episode 1 (‘The Mechanical Universe’).

Here, he recounts how in the early 1960s as Curate of St Philip’s Anglican Church, Salford, one of his tasks was to be an Assistant Chaplain at the local hospital. It was during those visits to patients in his capacity as an ecclesiastical representative that he admits to the religious difficulties that he faced in having to endorse supernatural explanations of their medical problems. How could he possibly repeat the prescribed prayers from the Anglican Book of Common Prayer to those who were sick? How could he tell a man dying of cancer that this devastating sickness had been sent by God?

Could he bite his tongue and agree that the birth of a handicapped child was a sign of God’s displeasure? On most occasions Cupitt reports that he summoned up the courage to offer the ‘natural causes’ explanation — that their medical condition was best described and managed by Western medicine, rather than by any supernatural causation or divine intervention. As a result of these encounters Cupitt was forced to redefine the task of religion in humanistic terms. At the very end of that first programme he declares: ... religion was a way of affirming the value of human life, from the first breath to the very last. It is up to us to give it that value: to affirm human dignity in the face of the indifferent universe.

Here is the ‘original vision’ of The Sea of Faith. The vision is to free Christianity of its supernatural underpinning and replace it with a non-realist understanding of the Christian faith. Cupitt put forward the notion that people must give up the realist idea of an all-powerful God ‘out-there’ who sustains and creates the universe. The word ‘God’ need not be abandoned, however, for it was still a helpful fiction that could be put to profitable use. He proposed that when people used the word ‘God’ they referred to a spiritual ideal: the word did not name a metaphysical Being, but the concept could help people live religiously. Such a way of living would blend the ethics of Christianity with the spirituality of Buddhism and could be described (to use the title of one of Richard Holloway’s book) as a kind of ‘godless morality.’ You can retain the Christian language but you must strip away the objectivity of God, denude the Church of its supernatural teachings and there will emerge a non-supernatural form of Christianity. This reformed Christianity can provide a framework for spirituality and ethics for humans who have (to use the radical catchphrase) ‘come of age.’ Cupitt describes it as Christian Buddhism: ‘the content, the spirituality and the values, are Christian; the form is Buddhist.’ Revising The Sea of Faith for a reissue in 1994 he reiterated his central thesis, arguing that: we might view a religious belief-system, not as a summary description of objective realities, but as a guiding vision an.l a programme for building a communal world.

Such a reinterpretation of the Christian faith met stiff resistance. In 1989 David Edwards in Tradition and Truth described Cupitt as having undergone something similar to a Victorian clergyman’s ‘loss of faith’ and called for his resignation from the Anglican Church. Cupitt replied that Edwards missed the point of his writings, which is not to eradicate the Church but to reform it. The best place for reforming that institution is from inside. Moreover he is able to stay within the Church as a non-realist because ‘Anglican formularies nowhere say either that the Church is infallible or irreformable, or that priests have got to be metaphysical realists.’ It is a bold assertion, and surprisingly one that the Church authorities have never challenged Cupitt on, though sadly Torquil Paterson in South Africa, Anthony Feeman in UK and recently Thorkild Grosbgll in Denmark have been put to the sword over writing similar sentiments. It also shows that revision of the Church is a major component of his original vision. This was reinforced five years later in his book Radicals and the Future of the Church. In 1989 Cupitt’s proposal for remaining in the Church and reforming it from within has two main components — ethics and human relationships. Ethically speaking, the Church is needed because ‘it is a theatre in which we solemnly enact our deepest feelings about the human condition.’ Furthermore, the churches have in the past served as a useful corrective to the power of the State, which historically has often been a cruel and oppressive institution. They have exercised their prophetic role in defending humanitarian priorities and individual human rights; their agapeistic values can counterbalance the selfish utilitarianism of the state.

Thus, lacking a powerful objective God, Cupitt resorts to an argument from antiquity: the churches are ancient organisations that have stood the test of time as fraternities embodying communitarian values that can challenge oppressive State legislation. The obvious retort to this is that the churches have exhibited just as much authoritarianism as the State, and have often themselves embodied the very power that one criticizes the state for employing. Indeed my own Church — the Anglican Church in Australia — is straining under cries of injustice in that it blatantly ‘covered up’ many cases of paedophilia over a long period of time.

Through his second concern, human relationships, Cupitt seeks to address this issue. He argues that a new order of personal relationships is needed, and he looks to Romantics and anarchists to supply inspiration. We fight not for a new creed but to discover a new basis for human relationships.

Citing feminism as one of many forces leading a revolt against patriarchal rationality, its structures of authority, and its hierarchy, he envisages the new churches being the same as the postmodern world: ‘a living horizontal network, a multicellular ferment of communication.’ The religion of the future is ‘dispersing God into people, people into their own communicative activities, and the cosmos into an unceasing, endlessly self-renewing process of communal artistic production. Our work of art.’ That original vision was slightly modified in 2001 with his book Reforming Christianity. He berates the Church for being ‘stuck up its own cul-de-sac’ unable and unlikely to reform itself; and considers that it is consigning itself to the heritage industry, which will lovingly restore and preserve it, unchanging and dead. He sees the immense progress that has been achieved by those organisations and individuals who are outside the Church yet who have been influenced by Christianity, in particular ‘human emancipation, human rights, humanitarian ethics.’ This is the reformation of Christianity — a desupernaturalized, secular, Kingdom religion. The crucial point to note is not that humanism has developed by itself out of a reaction to Christianity, but that secular humanism is ‘Christianity’s own struggle to advance from its relatively warped ecclesiastical to its final, “kingdom”, stage of development.’ The demise of the Church is not the end of Christianity, for Christianity is still unfolding in secular humanism. What we are now witnessing is a change of dispensation, as the Church’s own inner logic brings it to an end and Christianity becomes its long-awaited, post-ecclesiastical, Kingdom form.

It can be seen, then, that Cupitt’s flowing project has brought him to a point where he looks beyond the churches for the religion of the future. The new note that is sounded post-2000 is his admission that his writing is ‘not addressed to the church [but is] for me and others who think as I do.’ Cupitt thinks that ecclesiastical Christianity will be replaced by informal religious associations and networks such as Sea of Faith. Indeed he lays down the gauntlet for Sea of Faith to be the Church of the future. People should move on from Church Christianity, which is in terminal decline, to Kingdom religion, which is what secularism and globalization are pointing towards.

For Cupitt, this also is a way of recovering the message of the historical Jesus which, as Albert Schweitzer recognized so well, was lost once ecclesiastical religion became established.

Cupitt follows Schweitzer in viewing Jesus as a failed eschatological prophet who looked for a new realm to be established on this earth. Rather than carry out his message of an earthly kingdom, the Church deferred its realization to a heavenly world after death. In Schweitzer, Cupitt returns to one of the prominent ‘saints’ of The Sea of Faith, one whom he labelled as ‘the first post-Christian Christian.’ Cupitt too proclaims himself to be ‘post-Christian’, pointing towards that religion of the future based on the dream of a Kingdom that is this-worldly; that shows the way to religious fulfilment in this (and only this) life, and which secular culture has (much more than the churches) begun to realize.

To summarize this first section, I have sketched Cupitt’s reformation of Christianity from desupernaturalising ecclesiastical theology (the original vision) to realizing the ethical message of Jesus in creating kingdom religion in the here-and-now. We are the religious artists creating better worlds to inhabit. It should be emphasised (and is often overlooked by many of his detractors) that Cupitt’s vision has social as well as existential implications.

What I see is a challenge that faces us twenty years on, and my challenge, like that of Cupitt is addressed to those of us (and I include myself) in the Sea of Faith.

The challenge is that people in the Western world have not become irreligious, but on the contrary, have become even more religious, or as the terminology now puts it: ‘they are spiritual.’ Simply put, the ‘death of God’, the secularization of religion has not reduced the number of spiritual options, but rather has resulted in their proliferation. Apart from living in the greatest sporting nation in the world, I also live ina country which claims to be the ‘most irreligious place on earth.’ That assertion has been called into question by many, especially the Australian sociologist David Tacey. He argues in a series of books (Edge of the Sacred, ReEnchantment, The Spirituality Revolution) that today there is ‘a spirituality revolution’ taking place. It is being fuelled (to adopt Robert Forman’s phrase) by those at the ‘grassroots.’ Ordinary folk are moving away from the historic religions and forging a multitude of spiritual paths. It seems that people are already creative religious performers with a corresponding array of ‘artistic’ spiritualities helping to guide them through life.

Part ||: a smorgasbord of therapeutic spiritualities?

In a very revealing anecdote in his best-selling book, ReEnchantment, Tacey says: ‘After reading my first book, Edge of the Sacred, a cleric phoned me to ask why the new spirituality in Australia was not putting bums on pews.’ The unspoken assumption of this question — that the churches still have a monopoly on spirituality — shows how little understanding there is about the spiritual / religious preferences of the vast majority of the population. People in Australia are opting for what I would describe as a smorgasbord of therapeutic spiritualities. Spiritual options (note the plural!) are chosen by participants to aid their own personal well-being. The rationale from people is that they choose their spiritualities in much the same way that they would the wide variety of dishes one finds on a smorgasbord in a restaurant. If it tastes nice and promotes good health and well-being, then they will buy it. If it works (i.e. has therapeutic value) then they will use it. If it doesn’t work then they will discard it or will try another brand. There is a consumer, buy the product from the supermarket shelf approach to spirituality. Moreover, it is not a matter of buying only one product. As the Australian Anglican sociologist Gary Bouma observes:

Australians are likely to dabble in a wide variety of spiritual activities and not be bothered by what in an earlier time would have been seen as inconsistent or conflicting involvements. I know of Anglicans who consult their horoscopes, Catholics who do Tai Chi, Atheists who wear crosses, Baptists who meditate, Vietnamese immigrants who see no conflict in being Catholic and Buddhist at the same time, and Jews who seriously practice witchcraft. Spirituality has become an area of self-directed and self-assessed activity...Brand loyalty is in free-fall decline, product sampling is rampant and vast amounts of advice on how to do it are available on the web, in bookstores and newsagents.

Hence, the spiritual search for many Australians can take place with or without reference to the Christian churches. The former spiritual myopia that presented faith as a Kierkegaardian either/or scenario and resulted in people only being allowed to do it ‘this way’ has failed. People in the spirituality revolution of the New Millennium will, if told that “this is the only way,” as they have done in the last few years, simply jump in their car and go elsewhere. There is a new religious attitude that accepts walking labyrinths, meditating, yoga, the use of colour therapy, the Enneagram, Neuro-Linguistic Programming, the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator, spiritual healing, creation and eco-centred spirituality — the list is endless. Moreover, numerous and supposedly ‘doctrinally orthodox’ Christians are participants in this new wave of spiritual enquiry. Many mix this heady spiritual cocktail with more traditional forms expressed by ancient sources such as Benedict, Ignatius and Julian of Norwich. The postmodern return to the third person of the Trinity — the Spirit — is a return to a new respect for the sacred in everything. And, as we know, the spirit leads wherever it will. Thus it is commonplace for people to ‘pick and mix’ their spiritual paths.

Ihave had an eye-opener to what has been happening in the spirituality revolution since taking up the reins as Director of Wollaston College in Perth, Western Australia in 2000. Operated by the Anglican Diocese of Perth it was originally built as a residential theological college in the 1960s for the training of Anglican priests (and even tried [unsuccessfully] to lure a young Cupitt to teach there). Due to monetary constraints and a changed ministry model the students are now non-residential and only attend the college one day a week for what is termed ‘priestly formation’.

Confronted with a thirty-bedroom building the Diocese invested heavily to expand the complex with new Conference facilities. Overlooking the Indian Ocean and adjoining a national park it is in the ideal location. But who would come to use its facilities? Armed with a PhD in the life and writings of Cupitt I was the man given the task of revitalising the place! I think the Diocese had in mind for me to run countless Christian-type retreats in an Ignatian or Benedictine style; and market the Conference centre to the business world. The financial target was AUS$400,000 per year. You do the sums — a few ‘holy Ignatians’ aren’t going to bring in the bacon!

So, I (as they say) opened the place up to any group that wanted to use it. I have been staggered by the number of what may loosely be called ‘spiritual groups’ in a small city like Perth (population 1.2million) who have come to use our facilities. Luckily, our Chapel is in the style of Le Corbusier and was built to look more like a worship centre than specifically Christian church. Its unique design and coloured glass attract many involved in the spirituality revolution. The addition of a labyrinth has aided our appeal.

What I have experienced at Wollaston accords with much that Robert Forman writes in Grassroots Spirituality and what David Tacey argues is happening in the spirituality revolution. My experience confirms Robert Forman’s central thesis and definition in Grassroots Spirituality that:

Grassroots spirituality involves a vaguely panentheist ultimate that is indwelling, sometimes bodily, as the deepest self and accessed through not-strictly-rational means of self-transformation and group process that becomes the holistic organisation for all life It also reinforces David Tacey’s claim that ‘the one sacred reality manifests itself in different ways to different people...the Mysterious One can reveal itself only in and through the Many...’ Of course, for students of world religions none of this will be new. The scholar John Hick has been preaching more or less this same message for the last thirty years. In books like God and the Universe of Faiths (1973) and God Has Many Names (1980) he has argued for a theological Copernican revolution - God is the Centre - all religions serve and revolve around God. Religious experience of God is foundational to belief and religions are different human responses to the one divine Reality. Likewise, Bishop John Shelby Spong in his latest offering A New Christianity for a New World states: my hope is that my brothers and sisters who find Judaism, Islam, Hinduism or Buddhism as their point of entry...will also explore their pathway into God in a similar manner...then each of us, clinging to the truth...that we have found in the spiritual wells from which we have drunk, can reach across the once insuperable barriers to share as both givers and receivers in the riches present in all human sacred traditions.

This is not the vision of a new universal religion, but a way of dialogue for all those on the journey who have experienced ‘images of eternity’ (Keith Ward) by following different religious paths. However, what is new is the fact that those world religions are now competing with a huge array of local ‘home-made’ or grassroots spiritualities. The religious and spiritual backdrop has changed considerably.

Cupitt has described this as the dawning of the Second Axial Age — a period when people are rethinking everything. It could be summed us as the shift from letting the great teachers of the world religions (Buddha, Jesus, Mohammed, Confucius etc) tell us what to believe to being confident enough to forge our own spiritual paths and invent our own religion!

To sum up: I have presented you with what I think was Cupitt’s original rationale for The Sea of Faith and then mapped out the prevailing religious landscape — the spirituality revolution. The challenge for Sea of Faith is this: is its task to reform Christianity or to be part of a smorgasbord of therapeutic spiritualities? The question I wish you to ponder this weekend is: what is the agenda for Sea of Faith twenty years on?

To aid your deliberations, here are four issues that are raised by my paper. Firstly, what do we make of this smorgasbord of therapeutic spiritualities? If their emphasis, as all the evidence seems to suggest, is upon an “experience of something beyond” then does a network that has embraced non-realism and post-theism have anything to say to them? Has Nietzsche's realisation that ‘God is dead’ (like Nietzsche himself thought) come too early for those in the spirituality revolution? Instead of becoming gods and saints ourselves, even in 2004, people venerate something beyond — they still hanker after that sliver of objectivity: the feeling that we not alone and that there is something or someone ‘out there’. Are we a network that is just too radical for others to embrace? Does non-realism strike a chord with people's spiritual search?

Secondly, Cupitt himself says that he is unsure about the vast array of spiritualities that have entered the religious supermarket, for they have created formless anarchy and often commit the same error as traditional religions by producing dogmatic teachings dispensed by gurus and shamans. Yet, if notions of the gods have become disseminated by language across and within cultures, then why limit oneself to universal humanism? It seems that people are already creative religious artists. It could be argued that many of the newer religious practices fulfil Cupitt’s undogmatic criteria better than the historic religions, although he still looks chiefly to Buddhism and Christianity for his inspiration.

Thirdly, if we dismiss this spirituality revolution as ‘hogwash’, full of weirdos and a resurgence of the 1960s hippy revolution, and instead reclaim the original vision of Sea of Faith of desupernaturalising Christianity, is it worth the effort? Ecclesiastical Christianity is in decline and our nonrealist version has not met with much approval within its ranks. Should we not let the dead bury the dead? The Unitarians and Society of Friends have shown us the way with versions of creedless Christianity, so why try and reinvent the wheel? If you want a community based on a nonsupernatural understanding of Christianity, then join them.

This brings me to my fourth and crucial issue. Many within the Sea of Faith have walked out of the ecclesiastical doors and don’t want to go back. As one member of the Perth Sea of Faith group expressed it: “I haven’t set foot inside a church for ten years; and I feel so much better for it.” They are all post-Christian now and want to expend their energy in inventing new religious thought. This was exactly the complaint by ex-Sea of Faith member — Clive Richards —in the Sea of Faith publication This is my Story:

Voyages on the Sea of Faith (1998). His break with the Sea of Faith was due in part to ‘ideological discomfort’ with its ‘Christian perspective.’ Admitting that he ‘never really got much out of churchgoing’, he targeted people within the Network who were labelled: ‘Non-church, ex-church, whychurch?’ His main complaint was that he felt hampered by the membership’s lack of energy in seeking to create new forms of religion. For Richards, the Network wasn’t prepared to be radical enough and throw off its Christian heritage. So, what new forms of religion can we invent?

These four issues, I think, go to heart of where Sea of Faith is twenty years on from the most ground-breaking series of religious programmes that have been aired by the BBC. Cupitt is to be applauded for outlining the task that in order to purify Christianity and make it free we must get rid of the notion of God’s objective, personal reality. Twenty years on Christianity is fighting even more of a rearguard action, pulling up the draw-bridge and becoming more conservative. Heresy trials are being debated for those who rock the boat. At the same time, at the grassroots level, people are opting for a huge variety of spiritual options - what I have called a smorgasbord of therapeutic spiritualities. Indeed the UK SoF Conference in July, with its inclusion of the Saturday market-place, acknowledged that trend and reinforced the distinction I have made between reforming Christianity and alternative spiritualities. It is at this interface between a non-realist radicalising of Christianity and those who have already created their own spiritual paths that we in Sea of Faith meet in 2004.

The question remains: which way will Sea of Faith go?

Nigel Leaves is author of a 2 volume biography of Don Cupitt and Dean of Studies at John Wollaston Anglican Theological College, Perth, wetern Australian.