Carry On Seeking

Twelve months ago ANTHONY HILLS saw an ad for SOF in the Guardian, and decided to subscribe. But the product, he says, didn’t do what it carry on seeking I took out a sub to SOF on the strength of a newspaper ad.

It seemed as if here was an organisation of people who shared, if not my experiences, at least some of the conclusions to which my experience had brought me. Full marks, then, to the marketing department (or person), and although I found the product does not do what it says on the tin, perhaps my year as a SOF subscriber may provoke some useful debate.

Sea of Faith aims “to explore and promote religious faith as a human creation”, but it seems to me much more concerned to explore ways in which members can, in good faith, hold on to some connection with the church and the bible. It seems to me heavily weighted towards the problems English Christianity in particular raises for people who suspect religious faith is a human creation, but who have not found an alternative to the church as a vehicle for their explorations. It pays only passing attention to other faiths, let alone less institutional modes of discovery.

I don’t think my own experience is so unusual. Brought up in a church-going family with the church a focus for much of my teenage life, I studied theology at Oxford and Cambridge (fond memories of Don Cupitt’s graduate seminars!) with the intention of becoming a C of E priest.

Then precisely because I increasingly saw faith as a “human creation” I felt unable to complete my doctorate and move Here | am, with a wealth of spiritual experience yoked to a humanistic world-view and an enquiring mind - what, if anything, are they experiences of?

But attachment to these guru chaps comes at a price: sometimes monetary, always psychological and emotional.

There are times when, it seems to me, the Price is worth paying because what is offered is beyond price, but at other times it feels more authentic to go one’s own way. And in doing so, of course, unless one has been blown away by the grace of enlightenment, one tends to lose touch with the clarity that is so available around the teacher. At such times it would be nice to connect with other unattached seekers, to reflect on the experiences and learn how best to hold them in the context of a normal life and a critical mind.

Which brings me back to the SOF ad. Here I am, with a wealth of spiritual experience yoked to a humanistic worldview and an enquiring mind - what, if anything, are they experiences of? And if they are, or seem likely to be simply (loaded word!) psycho-biological events within the organism, does that matter? Ritual of some kind, whether sitting in satsang or participating in the mass, seems to be a potent means of transcending the limited self - what, if anything, does the mind need to believe for the ritual to be authentic, to “work”? What are the conditions - intellectual or existential - for effective participation in a spiritual community or communion?

These seem to me to be interesting and even important questions. They are the kinds of questions I would expect to find floating around in a sea of faith.

For sure, they are addressed by Don Cupitt, but in my four issues of the magazine | found them little acknowledged, let alone discussed by most on to theological college. “Truth” seemed a very unstable and relative notion, offering no basis for a career in which I would be representing a church which itself claimed to offer people a secure foundation for their lives.

What then? Radical politics for a while (these were the 60s), then meditation and assorted new age practices, leading to the first of two attachments to spiritual teachers, one Indian and the other English. Through these people I had what seemed, and still seems to be the kind of experiences which are written about in the gospels and many other scriptures. I vividly remember being around one of these teachers and thinking: This is what it must have been like! This is the essence of what must have gone on between Jesus and his followers!

The church spoke and wrote about such things, of course, but rarely as concrete possibilities in the present.

The direct experience of the Other was always elsewhere, in another time, for saints and saviours. Faith and hope were all that remained for the people in the pews. Pretty dark reflections in a glass. contributors. People talked about experiences, yes, but there seemed to be remarkably little interest in their ontological status.

I wonder why this is so. I understand that there is a critical moment when any impulse starts turning into a movement. The parameters start becoming set, the internal life and history of the movement start becoming interesting in themselves (see the considerable space given in this journal to the really recent past). And in the process the radical questioning which generated the original impulse becomes muted: even on this sea the boat should not be too upsettingly rocked.

But I think it would be a shame if the SoF let the process of stabilisation happen so soon, because the project of linking experience, understanding and the communal life is still absolutely fascinating; essential for the disaffiliated spiritual seeker.

And I like the new layout!