Beyond Belief

BEYOND BELIEF SoF talks to Denis Forman Sir Denis Forman has had a distinguished career as Chairman of Granada Television and Chairman of the Opera Board, Covent Garden. The son of a Church of Scotland minister, he is a convinced humanist.

Recently he co-produced and presented the Channel 4 series Beyond Belief which sought to "put religion on trial". We talked to him about religion, humanism and television.

What was his objective in producing Beyond Belief? "Our chief object was to allow views to be aired on television in their own right. Up to now, any humanist programme has been a riposte to a religious programme. Religion has had pride of place and has led, and there has never to my knowledge been any slot allocated to people who don't believe in religion but who do believe in a lot of rather important values." Didn't he have the opportunity to do something about that rather earlier, when he was running Granada? "Well, we certainly made the attempt! For instance, we did a religious series called Adam Smith which was a critique of the Church of Scotland, and it was eventually taken out of the God-slot when it became quite clear that the Marxist strain was slightly stronger than the sweet Christian strain! We also did a series called The Christians with Bamber Gascoigne, an account of Christian history which we tried to make objective, pointing out that Christianity had done a great deal of harm. But all this was done by stealth. I don't think the IBA [then ITV's regulatory body] would have been very pleased if we'd have said we were making a series of programmes knocking Christianity."

But today the IBA is dead, Channel 4 is charged to innovate, and Denis Forman's primary preoccupation is no longer the preservation of an ITV franchise. So to Beyond Belief. But the series was criticised - in the Humanist press as much as elsewhere - for adopting a confrontational format, with Humanists and Christians taking turns to slag each other off. Was that really the most productive use of precious airtime?

"What I wanted to avoid at all costs was half a dozen people sitting around a table and blowing off in a discussion without shape, form or purpose. Unless people are absolutely brilliant broadcasters, and there are not many of those around, the discussion format is otiose. We therefore wanted to bring some discipline into the discussioin and we opted for a quasi-legal format. Of course it wasn't ideal, the main weakness being that the judicial process leads to a verdict, and our shows obviously couldn't do that. On the other hand, the form gave people a chance to air their arguments in a disciplined rather than a flatulent way."

But what about those, again both in the Humanist and the radical religious press, who said "What a shame they didn't explore the ground that modern Humanism or post-Humanism has in common with modern human-centred theology or post-Christianity"? Wouldn't that have been more productive? "Well I spent some time before the programme went on the air talking to a most up-to-date theologian at Cambridge University" - Forman will not name the guilty man or woman - "and I came away with my brain churning. And I said to my co-producer Mike Darlow, 'Whatever we do, we must stick to simple issues the viewers will understand, and not get into theology!' Christianity at the very top is just about as unbelieving in Christ as anything I've ever come across! I mean, they've whittled the poor fellow down till you can hardly see him, he's disappeared in a puff of smoke! In the end, you couldn't actually identify what Christianity was. So we wanted to avoid all that, we just wanted to say 'Look, folks, do you think when somebody dies they go to Heaven, because we don't!' Simple as that!"

But didn't that mean that ideas, particularly those ideas which are right at the cutting edge of this post-modern society, simply didn't get aired? Instead, what we had was a very old-fashioned confrontation between a very old-fashioned Humanism still reflecting a 19th century optimistic view of human progress, and an outdated Old Time Religion. Surely for many thinking people, for the Channel 4 viewer if not for those who sing-along-with- Secombe on Highway, the debate has moved well beyond that?

"Give me a for-instance."

Well, there were growing numbers, including many within the churches, who wholly reject the premodern view of a "real" God, God as an entity, as a person or power independent of human culture, but don't think it necessary to reject religious language and practice as a means of affirming their values often the very values the Humanists affirm: human rights, human responsibilities. Isn't the important division not between those who still wear a Christian or religious label and those who give themselves a Humanist label, but betwen those who care and those who don't?

"Maybe, but we were not trying to address such matters. What we had in mind was that there are institutions like the Catholic Church and Islam which lay down certain rules for humanity which we as Humanists believe are wrong. We deliberately polarised the discussion between those who believed in the rules and those who felt free to accept moral values without any religious belief whatsoever. What we don't like as Humanists is that the Catholic Church doesn't let people practise contraception, doesn't let people read certain books, does take money off poor people. These evils are still very much there in your modem or post-modern society, and those who uphold them are much more powerful than the trend of thought you've been quoting. If my moral values are taken from Christianity - which, let's face it, most of them are - they are nevertheless more rational, more responsible, more dignified than they would be if I adopted them just because I was told to by some God ruling over me."

Quite so, but just as Humanists will often admit that their values have Christian roots, so Christian radicals or post-Christians will as readily acknowledge that their value systems owe a great deal to Humanism. Today we all talk the language of human rights, human justice, human happiness, human fulfilment, without any longer invoking the Lord God Almighty. We have a lot in common, so why not explore the common ground instead of laying into each other? Can't we find, or at least look for, a common language?

"Well let's agree that we can both get a lot out of the shared tradition, particularly in the area of aesthetics. First of all the liturgy, written in the most wonderful period for our language. Anyone who can turn away from the Church of England liturgy, having heard it, is a fool, because it is full of wonderful poetry. And the Authorised Version of the Bible, which rings in your ears for the whole of your life. And the painters and the composers who were financed or supported by the Church - all these are things I have taken from the Christian religion and regard as very precious. But certainly not the institutional rules!"

We agreed to drink to that.