As I Please: In Memoriam

John Pearson says let bygones be bygones.

It is appropriate, I feel, to remember people for the good lives they once led, and the good deeds they did. At one end of the spectrum there is the family man (or woman), providing a stable and wise upbringing, or the hard working local lawyer or doctor, pillar of their community; at the other, nation-saving soldier or statesman. These last are given not just a humble memorial plaque or a gravestone tucked away in a lonely, seldom visited, village church or churchyard but perhaps a major statue in a prominent square, or the naming of a major public building. But each in their way are in danger of coming under attack. Plaques, tombstones, statues – they're everywhere. A recent visit to Chester Cathedral brought this home to me, fuelling two complaints I have.

My first complaint: Church Authorities regulate any memorials put in church buildings, limiting the style and wording, just as they limit the size and style of headstones within the graveyard. Inside the church the restrictions can be very strict, in some cases prohibiting new memorials of any kind. I respect, up to a point, the need for a certain level of 'taste', both within church buildings and on the land surrounding them and, up to a point, the need not to crowd the inside of buildings with all sorts. But think how bare such buildings will begin to seem in future centuries, devoid of memorials of our own times. Think of all that we learn from the past lives recorded there. They bring to life the surroundings in which we find them. Some can inspire, others speak to us of our own relative good fortune, telling (as do many Victorian monuments) of whole families of children, sometimes as many as four or five, failing to reach the age of more than a year or so.

My second complaint is about the revisionist approach towards some who have gone before, whole histories whitewashed out by PC aficionados. Currently, in Bristol, the Colston Gallery is to be renamed due to the history of the leading benefactor after whom it is named, merchant and slave trader 1636–1721. In Bristol Cathedral the authorities are considering removing a major stained glass window which remembers Edward Colston. Around the City, it is suggested, schools, roads and the like should all be re-named. Only recently, in similar vein, certain students at Oxford sought to have a statue of Cecil Rhodes removed from Oriel College in the light of the terrors of Apartheid. Colston and Rhodes, and elsewhere doubtless others like them, are suddenly bad news however good their achievements were on other fronts.

I think we should make more allowance for the possible short sightedness/wrong thinking (as we now see it) of previous generations when times were very different. They saw nobility and generosity in the lives of those for whom they erected statues and wished this to be given recognition. Slave trading, for example, was not in its day, an illegal activity. Fortunes built on it, and munificently redistributed in the form of libraries, schools and the like, were not the ill-gotten gains of criminals. Might we reverse the words of Mark Antony, to allow perhaps that: 'The good that men do lives after them; the evil oft interréd with their bones'?

Such men as Colston did a lot of good in their day. Only now are the PC-fearful clan resurrecting their less savoury associations and punishing these persons in hindsight. Indeed, we should let it be known that society no longer finds certain practices acceptable, but covering ourselves in sackcloth and ashes and making fulsome apologies for slavery (for example) is, to me, a worthless charade. Equally, granting retrospective pardons to men shot in the Great War for 'cowardice' and apologising to the likes of Alan Turing and his contemporaries for the punishment meted out to them make a mockery of the laws which, rightly or wrongly, prevailed when they were condemned. In their own time(s), when they were found guilty they were guilty. Colston, in his own time, was innocent.

John Pearson is a semi-retired university lecturer and Chair of SOF trustees.