An Artist-Monk and a Poetic-Theologian

An artist-monk and a poetic-theologian Nigel Martin compares the quests of Thomas Merton and Don Cupitt There's a line from my Baptist Sunday-school days, a line from a chorus we used to sing that ends with the words: "My cup's full and running over". Nobody ever thought to explain what this was supposed to mean to literal-minded five year olds, but I reckon Don Cupitt or Thomas Merton could have taught us a thing or two.

The discovery that "fullness of life" is the very heart of the religious quest provides one of the keys that opens up the significance of both writers. Theirs is a universally human message that every generation should hear if it is to avoid the temptation of running too long on "empty".

It may well be a cliché to say that no two lives are exactly the same. Yet it is my belief that despite some obvious differences, the enduring message to be read from the lives of both Cupitt and Merton, is strikingly similar. Even at a cursory glance there are some noteworthy autobiographical parallels. For example: both were essentially converts to Christian faith, Merton to conservative Catholicism and Cupitt to in the end, all that really mattered was the hidden journey into the True Self and the Ground of All Being were the days of Vatican II, the time of the "death of God theologians", and when inter-faith dialogue between Christians and Buddhists was still in early infancy. In their own distinctive ways, Cupitt as philosopher / theologian and Merton as engaged contemplative, both men have taken on the worlds of ideas and social action in a manner so contemporary that their work still manages to captivate readers nearly forty years later.

Conventional beginnings Thomas Merton Radical is a term that can rightly be applied to Don Cupitt and Thomas Merton. However, like many genuinely free-thinkers, radical is not how they started out. Merton's bestselling spiritual autobiography, The Seven Storey Mountain, is still interpreted essentially as a work of reactionary Catholic piety. It is a classic tale of bad-boy-madegood, a twentieth century Prodigal Son played out against the Pauline framework of sin, grace and redemption. And herein lay the book's unprecedented appeal amongst a largely non-monastic audience. Dom Jean Leclercq, Benedictine scholar and one of Merton's closest confidants, put it aptly when he wrote that "this story was my story: I followed Thomas Merton's path and I middle-of-the-road Anglicanism; both attended English boarding schools and went on to Cambridge - Merton survived only three terms at Clare College compared with Cupitt's thirty years as a don.

Teaching and writing were their life-vocations and the socio-theological revolution of the 1960's had a profound impact on their development as prophetic voices of ecclesiastical freedom and renewal. These reached the end of it, just as he did." Despite the narrowness of his early religious vision, there was nevertheless a spiritual integrity and transparency in Merton's story. He seemed capable of addressing, both warmly and pertinently, a post-war generation (not just of Catholics) in search of answers to the tough questions.

Pastoral experience, gathered first in a Salford parish and then as Vice Principal of Westcott House theological college, was one of the defining characteristics of Cupitt's early life as an Anglican priest. Early publications and interests appear fairly typical of an academic theologian and philosopher of religion with works on Christology and ethics. It wasn't until 1980 when Taking Leave of God came out, that Don Cupitt's appetite for fresh and challenging thinking reached a larger audience than that of the seminar room.

Then in 1984 The Sea of Faith book was launched alongside the TV series, popularising the "non-realist vision" and granting Cupitt a memorable place in the wider cultural imagination.

I remember watching every episode as a rather bemused but highly orthodox "O-Level’ pupil. I remember also making contact with Cupitt by letter when I thought my faith was finished in my twenties. And the very first Merton biography I ever read a few years later - guess who wrote one of the reviews? Cupitt again. The figures of Merton and Cupitt have quite simply, stalked the better part of my adult life.

Conversion as a way Of life When monks take the vow of "conversion of manners", they consecrate themselves to the experience of being born again every day for the rest of their lives. This represented an utterly new theology of new birth from the one I had received within the context of Ulster-evangelicalism. Reading Merton is an exercise in coming to terms with the more realistic (and biblical) understanding of conversion as a way of life. The journey through the Merton corpus demonstrates with utter clarity, a life lived in a state of perpetual progress. Ironically, it was this very commitment to human transformation that made him both irritating and loveable at the same time. A gadfly spirit he remained throughout his life. This is evident in the ongoing struggle to comprehend the nature of his restless spirit and vocation over a period of nearly thirty years. Was he really a novelist, a poet, a Carthusian (with a solitary vocation), a peacemaker, a potential husband, or some new kind of Trappist semi-hermit, the like of which the Strict Observers had never known before?

Truly, there was something of all these things in the enigma called Merton. He was impossible to contain and to classify. His interests were so varied, his passions so deep, his reading so broad for one whose real business as a good Cistercian, was simply to "listen" according to the Rule of St. Benedict.

In the beginning all Merton wanted to be was a good monk. Later, he wanted to be a worthy priest and Novice Master. But perhaps what resonates most about his pilgrim progress is that his greatest desire of all was to become more fully human. The pursuit of authentic living and a living faith became inseparable. In his own words, "(He) really did want S of 61 September 2003 to write about everything" and that ambition was largely fulfilled. But in the end, all that really mattered was the hidden journey into the True Self and the Ground of All Being.

Don Cupitt too, still regards himself as a pilgrim of conversion. "Pilgrim" was the exact word he used in an unforgettable telephone-tutorial I had with him before writing this piece. His journey through the darkness of metaphysical dogma and religiosity into the clean air of "Solar Living” and "Kingdom Religion", represents his Don Cupitt existential rebirth - painted in the glowing colours of his very own "poetical theology". For Cupitt, the language of growth and transformation applies not only to human beings, but to language itself. This progress into self-knowledge he re-names as the "Eye of God".

And just as Merton relied on the legacy of Etienne Gilson and Jacques Maritain, so too Cupitt has paid his own philosophical dues to the influence of Wittgenstein. Both Cupitt and Merton committed themselves to a "here and now" understanding of religious life. "To live in the Spirit" for Merton still required the ascetical pursuit of the Great Unknown.

In a similar vein, some words of Wittgenstein encapsulate the Cupittian vision of religion cutting loose into "the Blissful Void": "If we take eternity to mean not infinite temporal duration but timelessness, then eternal life belongs to those who live in the present.” Crossing boundaries "Why shouldn't there be anarchy?" This question seems to epitomize Cupitt's uneasy relations with authority over the years. Proclaiming a faith without hierarchy, religion without anchors and encouraging sheep to become their own shepherd, was always going to get up certain theological noses. And it's this kind of "free-floating", make-it-up-as-you-go-along version of faith that leads some to suffer symptoms (if I can invent my own Cupittism here) of "vertigospirituality". So whilst Merton could legitimately be described today as being "very kingdom" in outlook, he may well have made sharp distinctions between the primacy of personal autonomy over church edict on the one hand, and the potential hazards of a total rootlessness in the spiritual life on the other. This is where our two friends, importantly, do part company.

The university and the cloister are two very different worlds; the philosopher and the monk do well in crossing boundaries but will inevitably end up feeling either at home or at sea.

Prophets have traditionally been heard from the vantage-point of distance where frontiers are uncertain and the air seems more pure. As far as monastic renewal is concerned, Merton certainly did exercise a lasting and prophetic ministry, not just to fellow monastics, but also to the wider church and world. Sadly, like Moses, it was for others to go in and claim the Promised Land. In the areas of dialogue and reconciliation with eastern religions in particular, Merton passed the baton on to other pioneering Benedictines like Bede Griffiths, John Main and Laurence Freeman. They would refine and enlarge the Mertonian vision by incorporating both traditional and radical forms of witness and communion.

Mystics, on the other hand, have always had a love-hate relationship with the ecclesiastical powers that be. This might well have something just as much to do with so-called "artistic temperament" than any message that the spiritual-seers have to offer. There can be little doubt that Merton belongs to this tradition within the church. Some have even argued that Cupitt deserves his own rightful place in such a hall of fame as well. But I'm just not so sure that Cupitt himself would agree.

Cupitt, even more than Merton, is virtually impossible to pigeon-hole. This is both his charm and his strength. There is, of course, a connection between the negative tradition of Christian theology and the work of Don Cupitt. But the connection may well be more tenuous than some would have us believe.

Cupitt is well aware of the big-hitters in this area like Meister Eckhart and St. John of the Cross. He has assimilated some of their terminology like "emptiness" and "nothingness" in the pursuit of an entirely new theological project more akin to Art than Religion. But for all that, his natural home is not among the apophatic mystics or within the biblical, prophetic movement. Cupitt is as post-mystical as he is postmodern. He may well be (and some will find this strange perhaps), closer to the spirit of Romantic Idealism - the figures of Wordsworth and D.H.

Lawrence he admires greatly - than we ever thought possible.

Merton and Cupitt might have grown up in the days of black and white, but they have done all their living in colour. And as the first Sea of Faith conference kicks off in Belfast at the end of September, I hope we can bring back human happiness as a worthy goal of religious life. It’s a dream worth dreaming especially in this part of the world.

Nigel Martin is Head of Religious Studies in Down High School, N. Ireland. He has interests in monastic spirituality and contemporary theology. He is also a lay member of the Church of Ireland. It is hoped that some form of SoF group might be developed out of the first day conference to take place in Belfast on 27 September and Nigel has been asked to co-ordinate the follow-up interest to the conference. 1. Patrick Hart (ed.), Thomas Merton/Monk: a Monastic Tribute, (Cistercian Publications, Kalamazoo, Michigan, 1983) p.95 2. Lawrence S. Cunningham, Thomas Merton and the Monastic Vision (W.B. Eerdmans, Grand Rapids, 1999) p.211 3. Don Cupitt, Reforming Christianity, (Polebridge Press, Santa Rosa CA, 2001) p-137 4. Don Cupitt, After God: The Future of Religion, (Phoenix, London, 1998) p.124 , CRISIS AND QUEST Rethinking God for the 21st Century Open conference organised by The Sea of Faith Network (UK) SATURDAY 27th September 2003 Queen’s University Belfast For some refreshing "Thinking outside the box" join Andrew Furlong (Former Dean of Clonmacnoise and author of forthcoming book “Tried for Heresy: A 21st Century Journey of Faith ’), Malachi O’Doherty (broadcaster and editor of Fortnight magazine), David Boulton (Quaker and author of ‘The Trouble with God’) and David Paterson (Anglican vicar long involved with interfaith dialogue and a founder member of the Sea of Faith Network) For further details and registration form contact: