Hampson’s basic argument, the Kantian critique of Western religion, will be familiar to people in the Sea of Faith. Belief in a transcendent God who is ‘wholly other’ is neither tenable any longer, nor ethically acceptable. As products of the Enlightenment we can no longer surrender our ethical autonomy in obedience to such a God. As I heard Tony Benn comment in a recent talk, "I can’t accept Jesus is Lord because I don’t believe in lords!" The ancien régime has been dismantled and with it the transcendent God that upheld its hierarchy. Hampson goes further and presses a feminist critique that we must go beyond the Enlightenment - with its norm of the rational, autonomous, male — to a society in which women are recognised as fully equal and everyone is able to relate as a full person.
Hampson argues that Christianity’s particular claims that the Christ event is somehow unique cannot be sustained. Christianity, she maintains, is untrue in the sense that there has been some kind of, "Interruption in the causal nexus of history and of nature". Our understanding of our world does not permit single and unique occurrences. If there is one incarnation or resurrection there must be the possibility of others. If there are others then the claims to uniqueness fall. As claims to the uniqueness of the Christ event are fundamental to Christianity then "What cannot be held to be a Christian position, if one is not to muddle terms, is the belief (simply) that Jesus was a very fine person who was deeply in tune with God". Hampson wishes to remain centred in herself and in her belief in humanity’s ability to stand on its own two feet. Is any kind of Christology possible? Hampson think not. If Christians remain loyal to a pre-scientific understanding of the world their theology is no longer relevant to contemporary life.
But how can they retain the myth as symbolic truth if the truth that the myth conveys is unethical, that we surrender our autonomy to God in Christ?
Can anything at all be appropriated from Christianity?
Hampson considers a number of feminist theologians who, for example, have looked to Biblical women as a source of inspiration. But she does not find this convincing. Unless those theologians’ interest is in women as followers of the Christ then there are better sources of inspiration in women of our time. Furthermore, she argues that there is a profound discontinuity between contemporary women and first century women. Women today have a wholly different sense of themselves and past models cannot advance their claim for equal rights.
Contemporary women have a self-understanding which does not fit with the external source of authority that Christians claim for their revelation or their literature.
This is a more fundament disjuncture than the fact that Jesus was male.
Ina chapter on feminist ethics Hampson analyses the symbolic, psychological and political structures of Western patriarchal society. Men’s sense of self as autonomous is derived both from their separation and distinction from their mother (and from women) and in the overcoming of the father as a means of asserting masculinity. Men need to spend a great deal of psychological energy maintaining this autonomous self in opposition to, and in competition with, the other. In this sense male dominance may be understood as an ego defence mechanism. It is not difficult to see how these psychological structures are played out in social and political terms and how male power continues to be under-girded by Christian churches and institutions. By contrast more material is now being made available about women’s relationships with their mothers and each other.
Women are discovering themselves not in opposition to others, Hampson argues, but overwhelmingly as ‘self-inrelation’. Feminists look not only to being treated equally but to a different ordering of society in which all can be themselves in their diversity.
This has major consequences for theology if the symbolic which has hitherto reinforced patriarchal structures is to be shifted in favour of a new theological imagination. Hampson adopts a Feuerbachian approach to religion in that the forms it takes in a particular society reflect the predominant values of that society. In Western societies this has been predominantly the experiences and values of men. In her chapter entitled, ‘Christian Idolatry’ she unmasks how key Christian doctrines—One God, the Incarnation and the Trinity—have reflected a male reality in which women are always outsiders. Women have been deprived of writing their understanding of ultimate reality. No woman, for example, would have appropriated a story of the threatened sacrifice of a child as a means of testing faith. She believes that as these paradigms are discarded, no longer serving a richer, more diverse and equal society, so Christianity will become irrelevant. Free of the Christian myth, she believes a new spirituality may flourish.
What place, if any, does Hampson have for God?
Though Hampson adopts a constructivist approach to religion she argues that this does not preclude reasons why humans have created such projections and she herself remains a theist. She maintains that the basis of theology must continue to be, ’...the experience of a dimension of reality which humans then name God’. This dimension is, however, fully integral to human experience and through which ‘..we come to be most fully ourselves’.
It is at this point that Hampson’s argument becomes very personal. She gives examples of her own and others’ experience of this other dimension and cites the work of the Oxford Religious Research Unit in recording experiences of those who have been, "Aware of or influenced by a power, whether you call it God or not, which is different from your everyday self". She cites the work of Schleiermacher in support of a notion of God grounded in the self’s receptiveness to a dimension which is more than self. What is puzzling is that although Hampson works with the constructed nature of religion she does not apply this to the constructed nature of religious experience. Yet it is surely this kind of internalised spiritual experience that men have also used to claim that religion is private and nothing to do with the political.
I find Hampson’s theistic claims the weakest section in the book but I also find her analysis of the central myths of Christianity challenging and painful. How then do I remain in the Church? I believe that Christian symbols can be and are being re-imagined. I believe that in the context of a local church understood as a spiritual cooperative, continued critical reflection upon the life, work and message of Jesus in the context of serious engagement with contemporary life can lead to the fostering of compassion and connectedness. What we must emphasise is not the particularities of Jesus as male but his message. Christians can learn to take their own authority as Jesus did, to free themselves from the need for a Messiah and to become their own messiah! This is to focus both on the good news to the poor (all who have been disadvantaged through gender, disability, race or poverty) and also to draw our attention to the inseparability of the divine from the physical world - what Luce Irigaray calls ‘a sensible transcendent’.
This can be done through deconstructing and subverting traditional signs, listening to other voices who have named God differently, including those in the Christian tradition who have been suppressed but who now can be heard afresh across the centuries. Some readings and re-namings may not pass muster as Christianity in Hampson’s view but they will retain some form of Christianness, some flavour of the Christ event. It may be that Christianity may die and I have no desire to preserve that which has become outmoded. But compared with many forms of collective activity in our day churches do seem remarkably persistent and continue to be sources of influence in society. Feminist perspectives must continue to disturb, challenge and transform all who choose to remain in them.
Ian Stubbs is Vicar of St George’s, Stalybridge.
Review of After Christianity (Revised Version) by Daphne Hampson, London, SCM Press, 2nd Edition 2002 (first published 1996), pb £16.95, ISBN 0 334 02886 8.