The tide of Non-Realism The concluding part to this series on Radical Theology ‘We've been busy over the last two hundred years or so.
Busy realigning our view of history so that we can understand the past in human terms and human cost rather than as a backdrop for events of supernatural significance; busy coming to terms with the Death of God and our own individual and corporate culpability; busy taking pictures of the birth of the universe; busy exploring religion as a human creation.
During this time we’ve undoubtedly encountered some valuable truths. One of these is that humanity commits crimes in the name of God, while it is humanity, not God, who pays the price. That observation is beginning to sound a little clichéd these days; every bar-room philosopher knows that religion has been the cause of more wars than anything else. But crucially, what is now being realised is that it is not God per se who visits war, famine and disease on factions of his own creation, it is actually a particular type of God; a real God.
A real God is a sort of cosmic super hero, who whilst toiling ceaselessly to maintain the universe also finds the time to talk to us individually on our terms and in our language. So, whilst overseeing the infrastructure of the Milky Way he can also sponsor your salvation and arrange for you to win the National Lottery. Although often found to be lacking Clark Kent's ironic humility, the real God is clearly someone worth knowing and worshipping. He is someone who is always on our side (and if he isn’t it is our fault). Moreover, he is someone who thinks just like we do; someone who expresses regrets over the unfortunate killing of innocent civilians and then sanctions the action that results in it. A God, if you like, of collateral damage.
The focus on reality results, inevitably perhaps, in a preoccupation with ownership where righteousness is all too often territorially defined. Peoples’ expressions of holiness and sacredness become geographically located.
Moreover, it is usually defined as a few square miles that God gave to them some time ago (no-one can be quite sure when, but as luck would have it they’ve kept the deeds, although they prefer to call it scripture). This is the ultimate in realism; real people, real places and a God dealing in real estate, portioning out small pieces of the planet to his special favourites, but inexplicably failing to make clear to everyone else exactly who owns what. Is this how history ends — the apotheosis of estate agency? Perhaps the proponents of consumerism and the free market economy know more than they are letting on. Or perhaps it is simply time to call time on the landlord, the vengeful old man in the sky.
If Radical Theology has freed us from all that then what non-realities can it offer instead? The simple answer is many. Philosophically and often ontologically diverse in nature, non-realisms can nonetheless be characterised by both their recognition of the subjective nature of experience and their focus on language. For non-realism it is in life’s milieu, rather than in the mind of God, that love and truth, the big ideas of humanity, are discovered, fashioned, refashioned and re-discovered again. An intellectual pilgrimage based on understanding that the value of the journey lies in the journey itself, not in the destination.
Indeed, what could ever constitute such a journey’s end?
But if we now accept that truth coheres to our subjective experience rather than corresponds to an independent object then that knowledge brings with it not redemption but responsibility. This realisation has resulted in the development of a number of different forms, themes, and values arising in theology with many of them displaying an interest in the more practical aspects of human experience, social justice and life on earth. In turn, for example, eco-theology, liberation theology and more recently animal theology have all shifted the focus from heaven to Earth. God talk, it would seem, is increasingly becoming talk about us.
So where does non-realism take us? Theology is anthropology writ large and the creator of the universe is a meta-narrative awaiting deconstruction. The Word is actually our word, our text, and our language. One conclusion drawn from this idea is that language creates experience. There is, so the argument goes, no experience prior to language, because it is only through linguistic apprehension that experience is framed. That view is surely too exclusive. Non-linguistic experience is all around us. A baby feeding from her mother, a dog chasing a rabbit, all are participating in life and experiencing something even though they don’t express it through words. Certainly, it is true to say that language is prior to the individual, but it is also true that people inform, develop and even create language.
The process is a complex dialectic but language is not just master, it is servant as well. A creative yet created force.
In this respect, then, it is perhaps better to say that language contextualises experience, rather than creates it. The contextualisation and resultant communication produces human interaction, society and civilisation. But if language is culture there is no promise that its product will be benign.
In fact history has shown the reverse to be true. High culture is often imperialistic and hungry for domination.
Salvation for the non-realist remains on hold and the only thing you can guarantee is that there are no guarantees.
Ever was it so. This giving way to doubt, this recognition of uncertainty and the possibility of a reality unperceived by philosophy has been a recurrent theme in human thinking from Shakespeare to the current day.
The American poet Wallace Stevens expresses it probably as well as any. In his poem Sunday Morning, for example, he rejects the precepts of an organised and culturally developed Christianity and the supernatural construct that supports it. As he observes, .. The tomb in Palestine Is not the porch of spirits lingering It is the grave of Jesus, where he lay.
Turning then to nature, he develops the idea of living in a world un-sponsored by deity, dependent on the quotidian of day and night, where quail whistle only spontaneous cries, and where sweet berries ripen meaning-lessly in the wilderness. Ultimately, however, it is an all too human uncertainty that takes hold of his imagination:
And, in the isolation of the sky, At evening, casual flocks of pigeons make Ambiguous undulations as they sink, Downward to darkness, on extended wings.
Dare we concur with such experience? If so then it seems that more questions confront us. Does the poet's imagination divine or create the ambiguous undulations of nature? Is God actually an imaginative and poetic construction rather than a philosophical one? Even, we might dare to ask, does the poetic imagination participate in or point towards a reality that lies beyond itself? Do we only get the point of Natural Theology if we understand it as a poetic rather than as an exercise in logic? This final uncertainty, namely, that the human imagination might intuitively participate in a perceived reality rather than create one, potentially offers a different horizon for non-realism.
The destruction of Realism and the death of the real God, the oppressive totality that destroys rather than enhances lives, is non-realism’s most recognisable and valuable contribution to theology. The result, understandably, has been a focus on this world and a rejection of the supernatural dimension of human experience. But if humankind is as much the creator of language as it is its product, then we must also be open to the primary experience that lies beyond both our social construction and our linguistic modelling, but which may be apprehended by our intuitive or poetic response to the world. It was the sociologist Peter Berger who recognised and championed the concept of ‘a fundamental affinity between the structure of (individual) consciousness and the structures of the empirical world’.
The question is, does human imagination project or reflect this ‘encompassing reality’?
Religion is a human creation. God is dead. Secularism and non-realism have combined to effectively overthrow the Marxist opiate - religion - and its constructed metaphor - God - that kept social order for five millennia. Yet here’s the paradox: the structure of non-realist philosophy is underpinned by the dynamic realities of experience and existence that may still prove to be its nemesis. But Radical Theology, even less Christianity, is not a fixed once and for all expression. Rather, it is a living, evolving tradition that can and has incorporated a number of forms throughout its history. Through its rejection of the supernatural, Radical Theology has promoted the importance of Christianity as a transforming social force. In the fullest sense of the term, however, it is perhaps better understood as an expression of Christian anxiety, a poetic that narrates Christian angst in a world that increasingly denies us the comfort of faith in the certainties that once stood before us.
Trevor Greenfield is an Associate Lecturer in Religious Studies, The Open University, with research interests in Radical Theology.