The Religious Self in Emily Dickinson Juanita Bateman considers the shifting constructs of a religious self in Emily Dickinson’s poetry as the poet explores her belief and disbelief Emily Dickinson’s poetic style is fearlessly independent and original, and her angle on religious matters is just as radical and challenging. Writing from within a strict Puritan environment, she struggled with faith, challenging received traditions and beliefs. The God in her poems and the religious self who addresses, confronts and wonders about that God, are neither orthodox nor fixed, permanent images. The images of faith in her work enact with startling honesty — with what could have amounted to heresy in her time — a personal journey of spiritual doubt and questioning exploration, with a recurrent theme of the conflicting desires to belong and to retain an independent identity. These poems explore the shifting religious self in its journey of belief and disbelief.
Her poem Wild Nights is of desire for closeness and unity, apparently with another human being. The mood from the opening is of intense longing. The object of desire 249 is an unnamed, ungendered thee", the speaker an ungendered I". On a first reading Wild Nights - Wild Nights! this can be seen as simply a poem of desire, with a strong sexual innuendo, but the Plea Tastcly the use of "thee" would have been archaic already in Dickinson's time and resonates with vn ae ee the language of prayer. The capitalised ‘Thee’ in the last line suggests a desire for a Wild Nights should be Our luxury! : mystical union as well as for human love. But the dynamics of this desire is not straightforward. There is a desire to be "in port" and to be "Done with the Compass / Futile — the Winds - Done with the Chart!" which are the imperfect man-made instruments that merely 5719 I had been hungry, all the Years - My Noon had Come - to dine - I trembling drew the Table near - And touched the Curious Wine - 'Twas this on Tables I had seen - When turning, hungry, Home I looked in Windows, for the Wealth I could not hope - for Mine - I did not know the ample Bread - "Twas so unlike the Crumb The Birds and I, had often shared In Nature's - Dining Room - The Plenty hurt me - 'twas so new - Myself felt ill - and odd - As Berry - of a Mountain Bush - Transplanted - to a Road - Nor was I hungry - so I found That Hunger —- was a way Of Persons outside Windows - The Entering - takes away - To a Heart in port - Done with the Compass - Done with the Chart! point there — such as religion and language. But the ambiguous lines ‘Rowing in Eden — Ah, the Sea!’ suggest an equally strong Rowing in Eden - longing for movement and the Ah, the Sea! open sea, the very opposite of Might I but moor - Tonight - "mooring" and being "in port". ta Thee!
The desire for certainty and union, whether in the lover’s arms or in traditional faith, is not to be fulfilled, as the speaker also desires to remain unconstrained and free.
The poem’s tearing movement in opposite directions, between the wild open sea and the safety of the port, enacts a conflict that is developed in the more overt explorations of faith and disbelief of her later poems.
A similar theme of conflicting desires is explored in I had been hungry, with its contrasting scenes of outdoors and indoors. Although filled with the traditional Eucharistic images of bread, wine and table, what is done with them is far from traditional. After ‘years’ of hunger, the speaker approaches the table, but the wine is "Curious". The ample bread too is unrecognizable from nature’s crumbs. A tension builds up then, to the moment of communion/ dining / consummation. When the desired is approached and obtained, there is a feeling of unbearable excess that causes discomfort, and a sense of being out of one’s own element. Hunger itself is redefined as "a way /of persons outside Windows".
Although set in the identifiably religious context of the Eucharist, the poem is laced with sensual language, such as "trembling", "touched", "ample Bread" — and of course "Entering", with both invasive and sexual undertones. Whereas Wild Nights used the secular image of a lover’s desire, to speak subtly of spiritual longing, I had been Hungry takes the religious theme of the Eucharist, to explore the conflicting, impossible nature of human desire.
Dickinson’s acute awareness of the problems of faith extends not only to the dilemma of becoming or not a member of the church (an issue that troubled her for years) but to exploring the ways in which we can or cannot represent God in language, and even to questioning the existence of God and afterlife. In My period had come for Prayer, the praying speaker explores a metaphorical landscape to confront the limitations of conventional images of God. Up in the sky of course, nothing is to be found but "Vast Prairies of Air", and the speaker then turns to the ways in which God cannot be described: "his House was not", he had "no face", and most significantly "no sign had He" — pinpointing the inadequacy of language to represent the divine. The final image of God we are left with is that of "Silence", before which the speaker is "awed beyond my errand", and abandons language for an intuitive, emotional approach to the religious experience: "I worshipped — did not ‘pray’" (my italics).
The poem I know that He exists presents a teasing God playing hideand-seek with mortals, but this playful exploring comes to a sudden halt.
The harsh, broken quality, accentuated by the alliterating 338 sounds on "play... piercing” and "glee... glaze" highlights the shift from the game of seeking to the horror of finding there is nothing.
Death here represents the frozen moment of truth, of absolute insight into the ultimate questions I know that He exists.
Somewhere - in Silence - He has hid his rare life From our gross eyes. 'Tis an instant's play. 'Tis a fond Ambush - Just to make Bliss Earn her own surprise!
But - should the play Prove piercing earnest - Should the glee - glaze - In Death's - stiff - stare - Would not the fun Look too expensive!
Would not the jest - Have crawled too far!
My period had come for Prayer - No other Art - would do - My Tactics missed a rudiment - Creator - Was it you?
God grows above - so those who pray Horizons - must ascend - And so I stepped upon the North To see this Curious Friend - His House was not - no sign had He - By Chimney - nor by Door Could I infer his Residence - Vast Prairies of Air Unbroken by a Settler - Were all that I could see - Infinitude — Had'st Thou no Face That I might look on Thee?
The Silence condescended - Creation stopped - for Me - But awed beyond my errand - I worshipped - did not "pray" - that the living cannot answer. The third stanza finishes with a dash, a pause far more ominous and brooding than a full stop: in Dickinson’s poetry, the dashes are often the intersticial space of the unknowable or unspeakable.
The final stanza reverts to "fun" and "jest" as if for comfort, just as in her one of her letters Emily compares herself to a schoolboy who, walking across a graveyard, sings to avert his fear. The feared possibility of God’s non-existence is left in the conditional future: "Would not the jest - Have crawled too far!", but is nonetheless —— and undermines the solid certainty of "I know that He exists".
These challenging, creative exercises in imag(in)ing God, however radical, can be said to have a precedent in the mystical tradition, or to originate from the Puritan idea of finding one’s own way to God. But a more decisive break with tradition becomes apparent in The Bible is an antique Volume, which presents the Bible as a "Tale", a text rather than Scripture, so challenging its authority. (Although the strictest forms of Puritan orthodoxy had collapsed by Dickinson’s time, the belief in the literal meaning and authority of the Bible as Word of God was still very much unquestioned). The poem describes the Bible as an "antique"; something outdated which retains value purely because of its antiquity. It is said to be written by "faded men / at the suggestion of Holy Spectres" rather than the Holy Ghost, suggesting a source that is vanishing and unreal, and not particularly divine. The speaker attacks the alienating tone of the Bible: "Boys that believe are very lonesome / Other Boys are ‘lost’", preferring the more creative and inclusive approach of poetry: "Orpheus’ Sermon captivated — It did not condemn". It is interesting that, whereas the gender of the speakers in the other poems is ambiguous, when it comes to explicitly challenging patriarchal and religious authority Dickinson adopts a male persona. (Dickinson sent this poem to her nephew under the title “A diagnosis of the Bible, by a Boy”).
It is implied that the "Tale" is worth telling, but the "warbling Teller" that would make it more appealing is again ungendered, hinting at the possibility that the speaker may be casting him/herself (and all poets?) as that "Teller".
Longing, questioning, worshipping, and challenging: the religious positions of the speakers in Dickinson's poetry are shifting and often contradictory. There is no unified set of beliefs in her poems, but an inquisitive, witty and creative voice, unafraid of playing with conventions — and even breaking them. Refusing to be fully absorbed by a prescribed religion, attracted by it while at the same time exposing its impossibilities, and unlike most religious poets who set out with a particular denominational agenda, Emily Dickinson explores spirituality in a creative, intense and original manner which, like "Orpheus’ Sermon" and unlike more conventional religious writing, "captivate[s], it [does] not condemn". 1545 Bible is an antique VolumeWritten by faded Men At the suggestion of Holy SpectersSubjects - Bethlehem - Eden - the ancient Homestead - Satan - the Brigadier - Judas - the Great Defaulter - David - the Troubadour - Sin - a distinguished Precipice Others must resist — Boys that "believe" are very lonesome - Other Boys are "lost" - Had but the Tale a warbling Teller - All the Boys would come - Orpheus' Sermon captivated - It did not condemn - A Bluffer’s Guide to Continental Philosophy On the History of the Deconstructing of Subjectivity . The brief guide to some key changes in our ideas about subjectivity since the | ae Enlightenment, beginning from the idea of subjectivity as self-present consciousness or self-knowledge. S ‘ eo gentece MEST gm gar mae og aN = individualist Theories These assume self-present consciousness and use it as a basis of all knowledge René Descartes [1596-1650] ‘Cogito ergo sum’. I think (and doubt) therefore Iam a self-present thinking thing (res cognitans), a rational consciousness.