Patti Whaley 0207 359 4869 or 101335.3561@compuserve.com David Boulton 015396 25321 or publications@dentdale.com 2001: A Faith Odyssey THE CONFERENCE REPORT The 14th SoF.a@nnual conference at Leicester, August 3-5, saw the usual mix of workshops, talkfests, experimental liturgies, worship sessions, debates and open explorations, all grouped around three central talks by Don Cupitt, Ruth Robinson and David Paterson. The three ‘odysseys’ are reported and summarised here. journeys, the meanin DON CUPITT’s talk reported Don began by reminding us that the conference title, 2001:
A Faith Odyssey, was borrowed from Stanley Kubrick's film and Homer's poem, invoking the ever-popular image of life as one of two kinds of journey: a pilgrimage, where the route and destination is clear; or a quest (such as that for the Holy Grail), where we know what we are looking for but not how to get there, where we may be "forced to conclude that the search itself was the point”.
In Kubrick's film, various journeys seem to be going on, but the characters seem none too clear about where they are going or what they are looking for. The Odyssey is even vaguer. Odysseus has lots of strange adventures with enemies, nymphs and enchantresses, but "when he does finally get home, he has the sort of wife - rare nowadays - who doesn't ask him why it has taken him so many years to get home, and who he's been spending his time with".
What are we to make of the old much-loved metaphor It is our secular tradition that is battling hardest to make Christianity come true! and g of life story that rises steadily to a climax of revelation and blessedness at the end of life. It is better to look for the meaning of life in the way one can always say Yes to life and find joy in the present moment." Nevertheless, "life can be meaningful, and can be a story of progress and achievement, even for nonrealists".
In the biblical tradition, the Jews saw Adam as not just a tribal ancestor but the ancestor of all humankind. The subsequent fragmentation of humanity into different languages and nations was seen as a punishment which could be reversed by a universal ethnic reconciliation at the end of history. "These hopes are still influential amongst us, leading us for example to establish a League of Nations, and then a United Nations Organisation, and leading us also to go on struggling for ethnic reconciliation and peaceful multicultural societies around the world... "The kingdom-world to which the biblical writers look forward will be a world in which people are politically equal, and we today are still battling to spread liberal (lemocracy around the world. The kingdom-world is a world in which the hungry are fed and the sick healed. The teacher Jesus himself ERS A SS BI SS SLT] feeds people and heals the sick, by way ol of life as a journey? "Are we going anywhere? Does our life have a single true story that gives it true meaning?" Once we could give a confident Yes to this question. We saw our entire life as divinely scripted in advance. "Your own life's meaning is laid on for you, not just as a personal story, but also as part of a grander, cosmic Story of Everything. That is what traditional Western theology used to provide... The Victorian believer sang: ‘Nightly pitch I my moving tent A day's march nearer home’. (They played the tune when the Titanic went down).
What of all this survives today? At first sight, almost nothing. We live in a vast, neutral and indifferent universe, and we don't know whether it will rebound from the Big Bang in a Final Crunch or oscillate in a continuous loop. "Nobody today is likely to think either that the whole of human history can be totalized in a single great theological drama, or that individual lives have to follow a script already written, whether by God or by the Fates or in the stars or in our genes. "We must now give up the hope of being able to read the whole of our life as a single, ready-made, meaningful demonstrating that the better world is possible and is near - and we through our great international humanitarian charities are still attempting to create the same better world today." The unfolding of the Judeo-Christian tradition is continuing in the secular culture of our own times. "A nonrealist can recognise that although Christianity is in steep decline in the churches, the secular culture around us is still inspired by biblical values and is still struggling to bring in the kingdom-world... It is our secular tradition that is battling hardest to make Christianity come true!" So "a Christian nonrealist who lives by Christian values and stories can do something to make a meaningful story out of her own life insofar as she contributes to the slow historical unfolding and eventual fulfilment of faith's ancient dream of a better world here on earth”.
Our life can be meaningful and worthwhile, therefore, "insofar as we choose to make it so, by the causes to which we commit ourselves and the company we keep".
There is even a nonrealist kind of historical inevitability "For example, I believe that when one has fully grasped the point of feminism, one cannot help but see that it is right and must in the end prevail - even in Islam, even in China. Some moral advances have a certain finality and irreversibility about them. I find that my old belief in divine providence has been replaced, not quite by Marx's historical materialism, but by the conviction that some values, some insights, are inextinguishable." But the Odysseus story raises another problem: how do we know that, in our journeys, we are really making progress? "Odysseus wanders and has many strange adventures, but for books on end there is no indication of how he knows, or whether he does think, that somehow he is getting nearer home. "And I similarly wonder how, or whether, I know that I have made any progress through all the complicated shifts in my own thinking over the past 25 years. A few months ago my Taking Leave of God (1980) was republished as a ‘classic’ just as I was finishing Emptiness and Brightness, and I couldn't help but be struck by the difference between my outlook then and my outlook -now. It is very great - but have I progressed? How can I tell? There is no truth out there. For years I have thought that all religious and philosophical systems are like works of art. Their truth is the truth of art. There isn't any objective standard by which I can judge that one of my books is good and another is way off-beam... "Most writers end up being admired only for their earliest books, which suggests I've probably been going steadily downhill for over twenty years! Bad news! But like a painter or a novelist I just go on trying, because one has to. But I never will know whether I peaked early and am now going downhill or whether I'm still coming to my best work, or whether my whole project has been a trivial and unimportant sideshow." Such considerations apply to the personal faithodyssey of everyone, suggesting that "we can never be sure of the stories we tell ourselves about what our lives mean and where they are going. This uncertainty is a challenge and a call to disinterestedness. Each of us has to do her own thing, follow her own light, go her own way, and affirm her own faith and values unsupported... There is no genuine validating authority, and there can't be." But there can, nevertheless, be moments of eternal happiness amidst the uncertainties and mundanity of life, if we "accept and give ourselves to its transience, its contingency and its ‘brightness’. I find it easiest to explain this in terms of painting. "There was a moment in mid-seventeenth century Amsterdam when the leading painters caught and expressed, better than anyone had ever done before, a kind of stillness and perfection and rapture in the midst of ordinary secular life. A young woman stands by the window reading a letter; a maidservant bends over a child in the tiled courtyard behind a house; and a patient governess teaches a rather slow child to read. There are moments when just light fills us with rapture. There are times when the beauty of the visual field is overwhelming. And there are times when just ordinary life seems religiously ultimate and in no need of any external justification... "A good society, for me, is a society in which many, many people can frequently experience such moments. They help to make us feel able to say Yes to lite.” odyssey RUTH ROBINSON’s own edited version of her talk My odyssey has lasted a lifetime. In my talk at Conference, I described my journey from a traditional position in the Church of England to a more inward. understanding of spirituality from within SoF. To do this I used the computer analogy of "God" and "Jesus" as the icons on my toolbar ( issued by Christian Tradition) that I had initially used to open up my own spiritual programme in a folder called "Christian Belief".