STEPHEN MITCHELL tastes Dr Habgood’s patent remedies for heretics and finds them beyond belief Varieties of Unbelief by john Habgood (DLT, £8.95) What is a retired archbishop (York) doing writing a book about unbelief? Responding to the Rev John Bampton, who stipulated that eight Divinity Lecture Sermons should be delivered “to confute all heretics and schismatics”? But why not take up the more positive challenge of “confirming and establishing the Christian Faith”?
This is a sad book. John Habgood says he seeks “greater mutual understanding” between believers and unbelievers.
He sees belief and scepticism as “necessary components of any serious thinking”. He acknowledges that “the culture of ‘While John Habgood has a historical perspective and is conscious of our changing times, retirement does not seem to have released him from his cathedra.” The very image shows Habgood’s failure to understand the nonrealist project. The present Bishop of Ballarat once suggested to me a way of seeing the difference between the liberal and radical agendas. The liberal perspective sees such figures as David Jenkins (the former Bishop of Durham) clambering over a cathedral, knocking off pinnacles and towers - belief in Hell, the Virgin Birth, the Divinity of Christ. Finally, along comes Anthony Freeman and demolishes the final part of the edifice, belief in God.
The more radical perspective stands across the river and sees the whole cathedral reflected in the water.
Repeatedly Habgood accuses Hampson, Freeman and Cupitt of rejecting the metaphysical.
Commenting on Cupitt’s image of belief and unbelief are both necessary”. And yet his tone is patronising and dismissive. SoF, for example, far from being part of a necessary culture becomes “the so-called Sea of Faith group”. Don Cupitt is not a serious thinker but a “mobile target” - presumably to be shot down in flames.
Habgood reviews the issues which challenge many serious people of faith. Some may be the issues which set members of the Network on their journey of exploration as they watched the BBC’s Sea of Faith: the massive enlarging of our vision of time and space which makes Christian and human culture look small and insignificant; the status of religious knowledge and understanding in comparison to scientific knowledge; the problems of finding a ground for ethics; our rich world of many faiths. But his conclusions resort to preaching and some of his episcopal pronouncements appear insensitive. The Islamic community were not pleased to be told that “Muslims seem not to have grasped the significance of the necessary and inbuilt tension between religious faith and social order”. “The fact that the Qur’an is beyond criticism only compounds the problem” compounded the ex-archbishop’s problems when the book was published earlier this year.
In a chapter entitled “Anorexia Religiosa”, Don Cupitt and Anthony Freeman find themselves in bed with Daphne Hampson in Dr Habgood’s clinic, suffering from the most acute of modern religious diseases. Freeman is in serious trouble “trying to have his cake and eat it”. Cupitt would appear to be at death’s door, burning out. He is indeed living “as the Sun does”, giving “life to all”, but we need not fear for he is not suffering from spiritual starvation. He is a “well-resourced theologian” who has become “a contented slimmer”. is a fine and moving thought - the abandonment of all our theological, metaphysical and philosophical problems, in a life which burns itself out. No more Bampton lectures. No more worrying about whether an argument holds water.” But this simply isn’t the nonrealist position, and Cupitt readers who have tackled The Last Philosophy, The Revelation of Being and Philosophy's Own Religion will know that there is a world of difference between abandoning metaphysics and adopting a different metaphysical perspective.
I now have three books on my shelves entitled Varieties of Unbelief. One is an anthology of writings by a wide range of authors including Epicurus, Hobbes, Voltaire and Russell, edited by J.C.A. Gaskin. The other is Susan Budd’s detailed survey of atheists and agnostics in English society from 1850 to 1960. Both of these books look at beliefs in relation to their social context. While John Habgood has a historical perspective and is conscious of our changing times, retirement does not seem to have released him from his cathedra.
In the final chapter, “Believing in Belief”, he too asks us to consider the “complex space” of a Gothic cathedral as an image of faith. The cathedral is never completely finished.
There are new spaces expressing new needs, new altars, new decorative details can go on being added. “As ina great cathedral, 2000 years of history have given us a complex space in which to experience both the simple directness of faith and its richness and diversity.” True. But as a former precentor, I can testify that there is life and faith outside the cathedral.