Postmodernism, Deconstruction and Radical Theology

POSTMODERNISM, DECONSTRUCTION AND RADICAL THEOLOGY by John Mann "Postmodern" and "deconstruction" are terms that have become important in cultural theory and philosophy during the 80s. Some theologians have tried to explore what implications the cultural and social debates on postmodernism and the philosophical debates on deconstruction have for religion and theology. This essay will try to explain what these debates are about and how they relate to theology, leaving it up to the reader to judge their relevance and importance.

To explain postmodernism we must first look at modernism. Modernism is the term used to embrace a wide range of cultural, philosophical and political movements of the twentieth century. In art - cubism, surrealism, futurism, expressionism etc ; in philosophy - positivism, phenomenology, existentialism etc ; in politics - Marxism, liberalism, fascism etc. Culturally modernism is characterised by alienation, death, anxiety, the refugee, fragmentation. Theoretically it is dominated by what are called "meta-narratives", stories that explain all, master theories which explain all other theories, whether from Freud, Marx or the belief in the progressive triumph of western liberalism.

The background of political turmoil, world wars, revolutions, economic collapse etc obviously explains much of the despair combined with a striving for certainty and meaning that dominates modernism.

Theologically modernism was very productive. Theologians such as Tillich and Bultmann were able to translate these modernist concerns with existence, SPRING 1990 PAGE 17 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE death, meaning and alienation into religious questions (although they explained it as translating religious questions into modern terminology). Barth provided the Christian meta-narrative, answering the modernist striving for certainty ; Bonhoeffer saw the birth of modernism as the "world come of age" no longer concerned with a supernaturalist, other-worldly religion and announced that religion must become ethical, this-worldly and immanent.

Postmodernists argue that our culture is no longer dominated by the anxiety and fear of war and revolution. Instead it is the mass media that dominates : the rapid series of images, words, sounds and meanings that pass into us from TV, film, video and radio mean that the world of modernism has gone. Auschwitz replaced by Disneyland, anxiety by consumption, alienation by advertising. Attempts to construct a feminist or Marxist reading from a pop video proves undecidable and irrelevant from the mixture of images and the speed with which they pass. There is "no more real" as the media scrambles every "world-view" with a thousand alternatives, providing too much information to assimilate. Culture becomes a pastiche from the past, but like any consumer item we do not need to know its origin to consume it, like the cargo cults we see its origin as magical.

Perhaps unsuprisingly theology has found it much more difficult to assimilate postmodernism than modernism. With none of the traditional religious themes of meaning, truth or death, religion has been swept up in the sea of postmodernism and made another pastiche from the past, another set of images and symbols to whirl about in the ocean of unreality.

What is often seen as the philosophical counterpart to postmodernism is deconstruction, a philosophical attitude developed by Jacques Derrida that has become an influential movement particularly in the USA. Deconstruction shares with postmodernism the idea of "no more real", that truth, origin, certainty etc are "effects" produced by various mechanisms operating within language. Whilst we can inspect these mechanisms to see how they operate and how the effects are produced, they are necessary for us to think and function and hence cannot be simply dismantled and replaced by "proper" mechanisms. To inspect how a theory produces "truth", to look with care at its mechanisms (for example, how it situates the subject and object) and perhaps to gently begin to dismantle part of it and show how it "works" is the strategy of deconstruction.

Unlike postmodernism which works within "epochs", the deconstructionist strategy examines a text (whether literary, philosophical or psychoanalytical) by bringing out deeper problems such as questioning western rationality and criticising its "Iogocentrism" and "phallocentrism", its prioritising of one term over another (e.g. speech over writing, man over woman, presence over absence, seriousness over humour, original over reproduced etc).

Briefly, the strategy involves looking in detail at a specific text and showing how different terms are prioritised to produce meaning, truth etc and that this involves marginalising other terms. Because Derrida's writings themselves question the "rules" of meaning they are often bizarre and unusual to read (presumably depending on how many rules he has decided to question I) but can be challenging and even funny.

Perhaps because deconstruction is more philosophical, a "Deconstructive Theology" has developed in the USA. The most famous deconstructive theology book is Mark C. Taylor's "Erring. A Postmodern A/Theology" (theology for theism, a/theology for atheism, geddit ?) which is written in a style similar to Derrida's, i.e. sometimes convoluted and tortuous, sometimes brilliant and radical.

Two criticisms made of deconstruction can also be made of deconstructive theology. The first is that deconstruction seems to be apolitical, is it therefore saying anything ? Since deconstruction is parasitic on other texts can it be a text saying something and meaning something in its own right ? Can you deconstruct one of Derrida's texts ? In response to this, deconstructionists say deconstruction is not a theory saying something but a strategy of reading, or even a strategy of strategies. The deconstructionists' use of quotation marks to show they are mentioning a term but not using it (e.g "object", "presence" etc) has been used by Derrida to apply humanitarian terminology to political subjects such as racism and human rights. In retaining quotation marks he is saying "this is the only political/ethical language available, but I remain agnostic as to its philosophical implications".

The second criticism is that deconstruction questions but never answers. Derrida may show countless problems with a philosopher's use of a particular term but perhaps never resolves whether those problems could be avoided. Deconstructive theology perhaps asks many questions of what a post-ecclesiastical religion must lose yet fails to put forward many positive statements of what such a religion contains.

In weighing up postmodern/deconstructive theologies the reader could perhaps address three areas. 1. The first is that postmodern and deconstructive SPRING 1990 PAGE 18 SEA OF FAITH MAGAZINE terminology is fairly widespread, not simply in academic journals but in popular magazines such as "i-D", "The Face", "Blitz", "NME" etc. Should theology fail to engage with popular culture and its theorization ? 2. The second area is the question of representation and dissemination in society. Can the traditional disseminating organs of the church service and religious literature actually have any power against the media ? This isn't a question of "should we have more religion on TV ?" but what sort of expectations, desires, pleasures, rationalities, sensibilities etc are created through the media and hence should "religion" and religious issues be integrated within the "postmodern subject". 3. The third area is how can we ground values and beliefs ? Questions of freedom, democracy, justice, human rights, ecology, animal rights, world disarmament etc are raised in a very specific manner. People don't want a revolution, they want change to be careful, controlled and effective. The idea of a clear vision of "how things should be", whether communist, socialist or capitalist is held by very few. Can religion keep this tension between a desire for a better world and the rejection of a simple, clear solution ?

Whether or not Postmodern Christianity is seen as a viable reformulation of Christianity, it seems certain that the modernist liberal wing of the church is now in decline. If we are to avoid deferring towards conservatism a radical renewal must come soon.