John Cornford 1936 Mr Justice Burton has recently been asked in the British High Court to assess whether the film on global warming produced by the former US presidential candidate and now Nobel Peace Prize winner, Al Gore, An Inconvenient Truth, was fit to be shown in our schools. His opinion was that the film is fit to be shown but has ‘nine small errors’ – statements that are ‘not supported by the mainstream scientific consensus’. For instance, the extent of the potential threat of future sea level rises is ‘possibly exaggerated’.
Most people would, of course think it matters that pupils in schools are taught verifiable facts. As far as global warming is concerned, it seems to be generally agreed that there is such a phenomenon as global warming induced by human behaviour but there is disagreement as to how soon a catastrophe may occur without remedial human behaviour such as energy saving. Such a film must not frighten children unduly.
Yes, most people would think it matters that pupils are taught verifiable facts – but as far as religion goes any number of totally unverifiable statements may be given as true and the government insists that taxpayers subsidise the practice. That is, taxpayers pay most of the costs of the voluntaryaided Church of England, Roman Catholic, Jewish, Sikh and increasingly, Muslim schools. These schools not only discriminate against accepting local children whose parents are not of that religion but then can teach their doctrines as fact.
It is sometimes thought that these ‘faith’ schools contrast with state or non-faith schools. Yet all state schools have a legal obligation to perform an act of broadly Christian worship every day. Sometimes the more enlightened schools ‘forget’ or camouflage it or stress a different religion but OFSTED will actually remove points in their school inspections if this happens. As education officials recently said when a headmaster in the north east requested to be a ‘secular’ school – this is not possible as religion is so firmly embedded in the educational system.
This becomes a particular problem in teaching about the theory of evolution in science classes if children are also told that the Genesis ‘creation in six days six to ten thousand years ago’ story is literally true in RE classes such as in Vardy Academies.
Teachers have now been given permission to discuss ‘creationism’ in science lessons. New government guidance says that pupils should be able to ask questions about the theory provided teachers emphasise it has ‘no underpinning scientific principles’. However, teachers must also ‘respond positively and educationally’ to such questions and be ‘respectful of students’ views, religious or otherwise’. The document, drawn up to clarify the rules after Christian academics challenged the teaching of Darwinism in GCSE biology also says that such beliefs are not ‘scientifically testable’ and are not valid scientific theories. This teaching depends very much on whether teachers wish to indoctrinate pupils with their own religious views and is very likely to be confusing for the average child. Good teachers of course would not indoctrinate but there is much scope for those who wish to proselytise with a ‘nod and a wink’.
The National Secular Society recently gained exemption for sixth formers to exclude themselves from worship. This took a major effort in parliament. So here there is a logical contradiction that such sixth formers will have worked out for themselves: Anglicans are confirmed at the age of about 14 often. Yet students who decide at 16 when they reach the sixth form or before that they see no evidence for the existence of any one of the various deities that have been put before them and are therefore atheists, are treated as incapable of such clarity of opinion. It is rather insulting to them.
When a headmaster in the north east requested to be a ‘secular school’, education officials told him that is not possible.
The Harm Done by ReligionToday Jennifer Jeynes focuses on religion in education in Britain.
Teachers in primary schools are anyway struggling to balance ‘inclusiveness’ with respect for different faiths and cultures according to the report, Community Soundings by Cambridge University’s Primary Review Group. The report found ‘Religion is an inescapable element in the current cultural melting pot. Jewish, Muslim and Christian religious leaders stated, as is obvious, to them faith was a fact of cultural life and a necessary part of education.’ The Cambridge review called for recognition in schools that ‘faith of one kind or another is intrinsic to culture and that it needs to be respected, whatever form it takes.’ Teachers should emphasise the common ground between the major faiths, in particular the monotheistic ones. It is very unlikely, unfortunately, they will include Sigmund Freud’s cogent analysis of Judaism, Christianity and Islam: monotheistic religions. He pointed out that they are all patriarchal, in that they involve a projected father figure. He further says they all have aspects of obsessional neurosis and hence are anxiolytic or anxiety-reducing.
Just think of rosary beads and the repetitive nature of the words of weekly or daily services.
Kate and Gerry McCann constantly attend RC services to pray for the return of their daughter Madeleine. I wonder what they actually believe ‘God’ will do. Is he/she/it amenable to persuasion?
Will he return the child if they have been ‘good’?Will he change the laws of physics and physiology? To put it in these terms highlights the contradictions for the McCanns, both intelligent people whose minds are still in straitjackets. What is clear is they are receiving social support from friends and neighbours at the church services and that is no doubt very helpful for them.
State schools must teach six of the major religions in RE. Teachers should lay out the basic tenets and practices. At least children realise it is very hard to ‘know’ that any particular one is absolutely true when all the others have devoted adherents. It can be upsetting however. I heard a secular Hindu father on Radio 4 saying his daughter had been taught at school about the caste system. She knew her father had been in a particular one and it was one of the lower ones. She found this very difficult to take in.
Some Muslim children are under more pressure than most because many attend madrassas, or religious schools as well as the primary schools.
Britain has tried to be very tolerant, under the banner of multi-culturalism. Yet this often means that the less culturally advanced parts of a religion have not been not criticised enough. For instance, the physical punishment used by some Afro-Caribbean evangelical communities, even considering children to harbour evil spirits which need thrashing out, as seen in cases that come to public notice eventually such as Victoria Climbié’s. Some Asian families insist their daughters enter forced marriages and take them abroad pretending to go on holiday. This is gradually being outlawed but is taking a long time. FGM or female genital mutilation is now technically illegal but it still goes on and some girls are taken abroad to undergo it.
The word ‘education’ is derived from the Latin e-ducere, to lead out, to think for themselves. Schools should be eager to teach pupils to think for themselves and not take received ‘wisdom’ based on the efforts of people many centuries ago to make sense of the world, on trust. How can this happen of course when many teachers have not gained intellectual maturity and are still suffering from their own childhood indoctrination? It’s not only indoctrination children may suffer from. I was very struck (so to speak) by the following account by Prof.
Laurie Taylor when I read it recently: ‘Corporal punishment at my Catholic boarding school had a mathematical precision. A small misdemeanour in class, a failure to remember the middle line of a poem or the correct answer to a catechism question earned a single slap of the cane.
But these small misdemeanours were aggregated and when they reached a total of six, the deviant would ‘Multi-culturalism’ often means that the less culturally advanced parts of a religion have not been not criticised enough. be sent to see the headmaster for more thorough and extended punishment… In this ritual, the headmaster always stood slightly across the front of your body so that he could grasp your arm with one of his hands and thus prevent you dropping it down to your side as if filled with pain. He then drew the cane back over his head with the other hand and brought it down towards you in a perfect arc, giving a final accelerated swish at the very end which made you think for a second.
Each of the twelve strokes was identical. No words were said. His ability to dispense pain and your ability to accept pain created a perverse mutuality. At the end, as you were dismissed, you felt that you had been part of a scene from a play, a scene in which both participants knew their lines and their moves. Is this really the way to teach morality and good behaviour?’ Quite often, people casually refer to Britain as a democracy. In my opinion, this is a very loose use of the term. Apart from the lack of an elected head of state and an elected second chamber which a modern democracy would possess, we have an established church. The Queen is the Supreme Governor of the Church of England and 26 Anglican Bishops hold seats in the House of Lords. This is actually an outrage – it is the only Western democracy that possesses religious persons in the legislature by nature of their office. Also, sittings of the Houses of Parliament start with prayers and up till now, the prime minister has wasted time he should spend governing, deciding which bishops to appoint. The church should be disestablished and as in the USA and France, there should be separation of church and state. Thanks to Charles Bradlaugh, who founded the National Secular Society in 1866 and his exhausting work in the late C19, at least new MPs can affirm instead of swearing on the bible though they still have to swear allegiance to the queen and her heirs rather than promising to work for the good of the country and their constituents.
Technically the queen is queen of everybody.
She should rule over everyone equally, Her church, however, sees a portion of the population as intrinsically inferior. I refer of course to that 5-10% that is homosexual. Woman are a bit inferior (if they are not royal) but at least they are now allowed to act as priests themselves (should they want to spend their time in a misogynistic institution) if not become bishops yet. Dawn French has said that when The Vicar of Dibley began, the TV programme wherein she plays a female vicar, she received a great deal of very unpleasant correspondence from Christian gentlemen. She seemed a bit surprised but in my experience the religious can become very nasty when their prejudices are laid raw.
The Church of England acts as if its leaders are moral exemplars – and yet they are on the verge of splitting over the issue of gay priests and bishops.
Not only that, the EU has sent out a working directive that insists that gays are treated equally in the workplace – this is clearly a civilised move. Yet the Church of England got itself opt outs, so that it can legally discriminate against homosexuals in its churches and schools. We – everybody else, can’t legally – not that I imagine we would want to; but the Church of England is allowed to behave in this appallingly immoral way and still expects to be treated with reverence by everyone else. A recent report notes that some gay adolescents in Catholic and Anglican schools are bullied a great deal.
The Church of England was aided and abetted in this by Tony Blair’s government. He flaunts his Anglo-Catholicism but seemed unaware that when he was following George Bush to an illegal war in Iraq, his prayers were answered by a different god than the Catholic and the Anglican one. Their gods were both telling their leaders on earth that attacking Iraq would be wrong. This is a prime example of the religious managing to find their deity happening to agree with what they want.
Religious people have to use quite lot of defence mechanisms to try and force their intelligence and education into sustaining a belief in the incredible. I would like to end by quoting Rowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury from a recent speech he gave at Swansea University on 14th October. He said that religion could not be viewed from a scientific point of view because belief in God was unconditional. I think he is worried about the recent upsurge of support for the writings of authors such as Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens. For someone who prides himself on being an Oxford academic, this amounts to a distortion of his intellect and a refusal to engage with the real issues. It is only by viewing religion from a scientific point of view that humanists and rationalists have been able to counter its worst attacks on a civilised way of life and harm for the human rights of all humans. This work will clearly need to continue for some time to come.
Jennifer Jeynes is the Ethical Society Librarian at the Conway Hall,25 Red Lion Square,LondonWC1R 4RL.