Religion on U.S. College and University Campuses

Religion on U.S. College and University Campuses

Religion on U.S. college and university campuses has been of growing interest in the States for over a decade now. Scholars have scrutinised the place of religion at church-related, or denominational, colleges; have surveyed college and university students regarding their religious beliefs and practices, and have studied the ways in which religion is taught in academic departments of religious studies. In addition, private endowments and other granting agencies have made rather large sums of money available for various kinds of religious programmes on campus. My intent in this article is to survey some of the most important parts of these scholarly and institutional developments, hoping to give readers in the U.K. and beyond a better understanding of the American scene.

1. Context

I want, first of all, however, to remind readers of three trends. I will simply assert them rather than describe them in detail. First, since the 1980s, the cultural and political power of conservative Christians in the U.S. has been growing, both inside and outside the academy. Second, the U.S Supreme Court since then has been rendering decisions that are more and more likely to protect religious expression on public campuses and to force public universities to provide free access to university facilities and funds to student religious groups.1 Third, the emergence of radical Islamic groups and ideologies has lent a new urgency to the study of religion in the academy and among those who oversee national foreign policy and internal security.

The first means that colleges and universities have come under heavy criticism for alleged secularism and antireligious bias by conservative ‘insiders,’ some of whom are on the faculties of rather prestigious universities. The second means that colleges and universities may no longer refuse the use of facilities and the funding out of student activity fees to explicitly religious student organisations. In the past, many public universities had refused to fund religious organisations on the basis of the ‘separation of church and state.’ The third trend means that there is more interest in and support for the academic study of religion, especially Islam, than perhaps there was a decade ago.

2. The Secularism Debate

For many of us scholars of U.S. religion and culture, the first round in the religion-on-campus debate came in a series of books by religiously conservative scholars arguing that even church-related colleges2 have become very secularised – have given up their sectarian religious identity altogether, or had so marginalised it as to make it virtually meaningless. Probably the most influential of these is George M. Marsden’s, The Soul of the American University: From Protestant Establishment to Established Nonbelief (1994).

Marsden has held positions at Calvin College, a college of the Christian Reformed Church (of Dutch origin); Duke University; and is now in the University of Notre Dame.

Perhaps the most shrill and hostile critique of contemporary church-related higher education came from James Tunstead Burtchaell, then on the faculty of the University of Notre Dame, in his book, The Dying of the Light: The Disengagement of Colleges and Universities from Their Christian Churches (1998). The third most important book in this group is by Robert Benne, Quality with Soul: How Six Premier Colleges and Universities Keep Faith with Their Religious Traditions (2001).

The research project that Conrad Cherry, Amanda Porterfield, and I undertook in the late 1990s, Religion on Campus (2001), was an attempt to respond to the criticism of those I mention above by looking at the college and university experience from a student perspective. What is the nature of religious life on campus for students? How is religion actually practised and taught on campus? Do students experience a secularised environment on campus?

In order to answer these kinds of questions, we spent significant time on four campuses – a Roman Catholic university, a Lutheran liberal arts college, a historically Black Presbyterian college, and a large public research university with a religious studies department. We were on campus as participant observers attending religious worship and other functions on campus; sitting in on religious studies courses; and interviewing students, faculty, administrators, and campus ministers, and the like.

We discovered that the ethos of these campuses was not anti-religion, but rather conducive to religious expression and belief. Students had a wide range of options for religious community, practice, and study – more options than they utilised.

Betty A. DeBerg from the University of Northern Iowa presents some of her research on the current state of religion among US students.

Certainly there is more religious pluralism on U.S. college and university campuses than ever before (the large state university I studied had over 30 officially registered student religious organisations), so perhaps these places are less ‘Christian’ in that there are more students, faculty, and staff on campus who are adherents of religions other than Christianity. But being less Christian does not mean being less religious, or that the undergraduate culture was any less religious in the 1990s than it had been generations back.

And certainly, as well, most academic departments of religion, or religious studies, now teach a wide range of religious traditions rather than mostly courses on Christianity as they did in the past, so that part of the university may look less ‘Christian,’ as well. But we found no strong institutional bias against or barriers to religious practice at these schools. In fact, we found that religious practice among students was encouraged by campus officials because it promoted community, increased student retention, and provided extracurricular social options beyond binge drinking and the bar scene.

3. The Religious Lives of College and University Students

The Religion on Campus project has not been the only analysis of college and university student religiosity in the U.S. The Higher Education Research Institute (HERI) at the University of California, Los Angeles, conducted a major national survey of college students’ spiritual lives in the early 2000s. HERI researchers surveyed 112,000 students at 236 diverse colleges and universities. Results indicate that this generation of American students is highly ‘religious’ and even more ‘spiritual.’ On the spirituality scale, 83 percent ‘believe in the sacredness of life,’ and 80 percent ‘have an interest in spirituality.’ On the religiousness scale, 79 percent ‘believe in God,’ and 81 percent ‘attended religious services.’ Words are always easier than actions, though. On the spirituality scale, only 47 percent ‘seek out opportunities to help me grow spiritually,’ and on the religiousness scale, only 40 percent ‘follow religious teachings in everyday life,’ although 82 percent performed volunteer work before they entered college and 70 per cent report that they are ‘trying to change things that are unfair in the world.’ There may be an internal disconnect between students’ perceived religious or spiritual lives and their activities and career goals. Also, many high school students in the U.S. do volunteer and charitable work because activities such as these look good on college and university applications for admission and scholarships.

College students are religious in ways that tend to support the ‘two-party system’ in U.S. religion – one party that is socially and religiously conservative and expresses little religious scepticism, the other socially and religiously liberal with higher degrees of scepticism, ecumenical worldview and ethic of caring. The survey indicated vast differences between the two parties in opinions about legalised abortion, sex outside of marriage, same-sex marriage, and legalised marijuana. Little difference between religious conservatives and liberals was discovered on issues of the death penalty (most believe it should not be abolished), role of women, racial discrimination, affirmative action, and gun control (most support it).

There are high levels of tolerance across these two parties, also. Christian exclusiveness is on the wane in this generation. Eighty-three percent agreed that ‘non-religious people can lead lives that are just as moral as those of religious believers,’ and 64 per cent that ‘most people can grow spiritually without being religious.’ And 63 per cent disagreed with the statement that ‘people who don’t believe in God will be punished.’3 Many observers of college and university students have made the claim that current students seem to be more religious than the previous generation – that there is a kind of religious revival on campus. This is difficult to substantiate apart from hunches and anecdotal evidence.

Studies of the religious attitudes and practices of current students will, however, give us a sound basis upon which to compare them with future student generations.

College and university officers charged most directly with student extracurricular life on campus, those who work in Student Affairs departments and the like, in the last decade have become much more interested in religion. The meetings and conferences sponsored by the professional associations for student affairs officers, for example, now include more papers and other programmes about religion on campus, the religious lives of college students, and the religious/spiritual dimensions of young adult development.

A handful of large private foundations have given rather large sums of money in support of religion on campus. These grant-funded projects are too numerous to even list here, so a couple of examples will have to suffice.

The John Templeton Foundation funded the HERI study described above, as well as the Journal of College and Character, an on-line journal published by the Hardee Center for Leadership and Ethics in Higher Education at Florida State University. This journal often publishes articles about spirituality and religion, as well as on the topics of leadership and ethics mentioned in its name.4 Perhaps the largest current privately-funded initiative affecting the religious lives of college students as been the ‘Programs for the Theological Exploration of Vocation,’ funded by Lilly Endowment Inc. Eighty-eight church-related colleges and universities in the U.S. were awarded approximately $2 million each to design classroom and extracurricular programs that engage students in theological, or religious, reflection on the vocational decisions they face and the career decisions they will make upon graduation.5

4. The Academic Study of Religion

Another contested point about religion on campus is the nature of the academic study of religion as it is taught in college classrooms. Charges have been levelled by conservative Christians that a critical approach to religious texts, beliefs, and practices ‘destroys the faith’ of students.

So the Religion on Campus research team sat in on religious studies courses, interviewed faculty members who taught them, and surveyed students in their classes to try to get a better idea of how religion, or religious studies, is actually taught on campus. We found that, virtually across the board, faculty approached their subject matter with an empathetic but critical/analytic approach that respected religious traditions and religious people at the same time that the scholarly perspectives and tools of university disciplines were used to analyse religious phenomena. Yet, religiously conservative students in religious studies courses did not complain in the surveys we conducted that their faith had been weakened or destroyed by their college or university religious studies courses.

But other scholars are not as happy with the academic study of religion as were we. For a history of the academic study of religion in the U.S. (and of the American Academy of Religion, which is the scholarly association for religion professors) as well as a very pointed criticism of the field from a conservative Christian scholar, see D. G. Hart, The University Gets Religion: Religious Studies in American Higher Education (1999). Hart portrays the academic study of religion as a misguided field founded and maintained over the years by people with dubious motives.

5. Conclusion

I hope it is now obvious that the study of the religious lives of college and university students, as well as the teaching of religion on these campuses, is a burgeoning topic for scholarly research and professional concern in the U.S. It is fair to say that in the past, scholars of U.S. religion have not attended sufficiently to generational aspects of religious belief and practice, so attention to young adults is long overdue (as is attention to the religious lives of children, for example). At the same time, those who have been charged with overseeing the extracurricular, non-academic opportunities for students enrolled in colleges and universities have in the past often neglected the religious or spiritual dimensions of personal identity and campus community, so the developments I describe here are also overdue. And as a practitioner and teacher of the academic study of religion, I believe strongly that healthy and well-supported religious studies departments at colleges and universities are vital to understanding one’s own culture as well as the perspectives and practices of those in other cultures. So what, in my judgment, was begun by a conservative Christian lament over the secularisation of higher education in the U.S. has become a multi-faceted and rich movement consisting of scholarly analysis and pragmatic institutional strategies all focused on the teaching and practice of religion on campuses and the religious lives of the students who inhabit them.

1 There are two main categories of institutions of higher education in the U.S.: public (or state-supported) universities, and private colleges and universities. Many of the private colleges and universities were established and are still operated by religious organisations.

2 By ‘church-related,’ or ‘denominational,’ I mean colleges and universities that were founded and are still governed by large national religious bodies or ‘denominations,’ such as the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America which is the largest Lutheran denomination in the U.S., or the Roman Catholic Church, or the United Methodist Church, or the Southern Baptist Convention.

3 Results of this survey are published as, The Spiritual Life of College Students: A National Study of College Students’ Search for Meaning and Purpose. Available online: http://spirituality.ucla.edu/reports/index.html. In addition, Anna Greenberg conducted a study of 18-25 year-olds, the report of which, OMG! How Generation Y Is Redefining Faith in The iPod Era, is available online: http://www.rebooters.net/poll/rebootpoll.pdf.

4 http://www.collegevalues.org/

5 http://www.ptev.org

Betty DeBerg, who holds a PhD in Religion from Vanderbilt University, is Professor of Religion and Head of the Department of Philosophy and Religion at the University of Northern Iowa. She is currently working on a major research project, funded by Lilly Endowment Inc., ‘The National Study of Campus Ministries.’